QUINTESSENTIALS Proposal intake / P48-45
P48-45
What gets measured gets gamed
Current proposed roles · editorial proposals, not accepted Card definitions.
Not acceptedConcept identity review
- Input id
- P48-45
- Original title
- What gets measured gets gamed
- Identity candidate ref
- QE-EX-METRIC
- Identity review status
- candidate_fixture_seed_reuse
- Historical roles recovered
- False
- Accepted identity
- False
Card coverage
Fixture only
Proposed concept boundary: Consequential metrics can induce adaptation that degrades their intended informativeness.
Open decision
Review the fixture identity and five contributions, including provider reuse; it is not an authored QE48 Card simply because an example exists.
Missing work
- Review concept identity and role ownership before authoring a Card.
- Author role-local scope, logic and required method, diagnostic, objective or action content for the selected functions.
- Record exact inspected sources and transformations, or explicitly review QE editorial synthesis with assertion-level evidence limits.
- Obtain editorial acceptance separately from structural validation.
Complete coverage record
- Input id
- P48-45
- Original title
- What gets measured gets gamed
- Candidate identity ref
- QE-EX-METRIC
- Proposed concept boundary
- Consequential metrics can induce adaptation that degrades their intended informativeness.
- Active role refs
- P48-45/O1
- P48-45/O2
- P48-45/E1
- P48-45/E2
- P48-45/D1
- Held role refs
- None recorded
- Authored card ref
- Not specified
- Fixture identity ref
- QE-EX-METRIC
- Related authored card refs
- QE-EX-INCENTIVES
- Ownership case refs
- R18C-03
- R18C-04
- R19C-40
- R19C-43
- R19C-63
- R19C-64
- Coverage status
- fixture_only
- Unresolved decision
- Review the fixture identity and five contributions, including provider reuse; it is not an authored QE48 Card simply because an example exists.
- Missing work
- Review concept identity and role ownership before authoring a Card.
- Author role-local scope, logic and required method, diagnostic, objective or action content for the selected functions.
- Record exact inspected sources and transformations, or explicitly review QE editorial synthesis with assertion-level evidence limits.
- Obtain editorial acceptance separately from structural validation.
- Accepted identity
- False
- Evidence status
- title_derived_editorial_proposal_not_verified
P48-45/D1 · Decision
Design implication
Use the specified independent-outcome comparison before relying on a consequential proxy to change rewards; do not treat it as completed when its required observation is unavailable.
Super rootOptimization & Control
Root familyGovernance
Parent familyNot assigned
Principle familyMetric Governance
data/reconciliation/qe48-checkpoint4-resolutions.json
Review status and complete proposal
- Input id
- P48-45
- Title
- What gets measured gets gamed
- Owner ref
- QE-EX-METRIC
- Role id
- D1
- Stack
- Decision
- Proposed role type
- design_implication
- Effective role summary
- Use the specified independent-outcome comparison before relying on a consequential proxy to change rewards; do not treat it as completed when its required observation is unavailable.
- Summary source
- Path
- data/reconciliation/qe48-checkpoint4-resolutions.json
- Collection
- rows
- Input id
- P48-45
- Stack
- Decision
- Role id
- D1
- Authority
- editorial_semantic_proposal
- Legacy summary ref
- data/reconciliation/qe48-checkpoint4-resolutions.json#P48-45/Decision/D1
- Adopted family ref
- QEF-D-MET
- Full family path
- Super root
- Family id
- QEF-D-GOV
- Label
- Optimization & Control
- Root family
- Family id
- QEF-D-DES
- Label
- Governance
- Parent family
- Not specified
- Principle family
- Family id
- QEF-D-MET
- Label
- Metric Governance
- Family precision
- provisional_principle_family
- Review status
- review_required_title_inferred_or_fixture_based
- Human accepted
- False
- Role ref
- P48-45/D1
- Record kind
- active_proposal
- Canonical type supported
- True
- Canonical readiness
- not_assessed_not_approved
P48-45/E1 · Epistemic
Epistemic bottleneck
Treating proxy improvement as sufficient evidence of better service can conceal divergence.
Super rootDistortion & Bias
Root familyBiased Evidence Evaluation
Parent familyNot assigned
Principle familyProxy Substitution
data/reconciliation/qe48-checkpoint4-resolutions.json
Review status and complete proposal
- Input id
- P48-45
- Title
- What gets measured gets gamed
- Owner ref
- QE-EX-METRIC
- Role id
- E1
- Stack
- Epistemic
- Proposed role type
- epistemic_bottleneck
- Effective role summary
- Treating proxy improvement as sufficient evidence of better service can conceal divergence.
- Summary source
- Path
- data/reconciliation/qe48-checkpoint4-resolutions.json
- Collection
- rows
- Input id
- P48-45
- Stack
- Epistemic
- Role id
- E1
- Authority
- editorial_semantic_proposal
- Legacy summary ref
- data/reconciliation/qe48-checkpoint4-resolutions.json#P48-45/Epistemic/E1
- Adopted family ref
- QEF-E-SUB
- Full family path
- Super root
- Family id
- QEF-E-BIAS
- Label
- Distortion & Bias
- Root family
- Family id
- QEF-E-BIASED-EVAL
- Label
- Biased Evidence Evaluation
- Parent family
- Not specified
- Principle family
- Family id
- QEF-E-SUB
- Label
- Proxy Substitution
- Family precision
- provisional_principle_family
- Review status
- review_required_title_inferred_or_fixture_based
- Human accepted
- False
- Role ref
- P48-45/E1
- Record kind
- active_proposal
- Canonical type supported
- True
- Canonical readiness
- not_assessed_not_approved
P48-45/E2 · Epistemic
Reasoning method
A proxy-divergence check compares measured progress with independently observed outcomes.
Super rootRepresentation & Models
Root familyModel Evaluation
Parent familyNot assigned
Principle familyProxy Validation
data/reconciliation/qe48-checkpoint4-resolutions.json
Review status and complete proposal
- Input id
- P48-45
- Title
- What gets measured gets gamed
- Owner ref
- QE-EX-METRIC
- Role id
- E2
- Stack
- Epistemic
- Proposed role type
- reasoning_method
- Effective role summary
- A proxy-divergence check compares measured progress with independently observed outcomes.
- Summary source
- Path
- data/reconciliation/qe48-checkpoint4-resolutions.json
- Collection
- rows
- Input id
- P48-45
- Stack
- Epistemic
- Role id
- E2
- Authority
- editorial_semantic_proposal
- Legacy summary ref
- data/reconciliation/qe48-checkpoint4-resolutions.json#P48-45/Epistemic/E2
- Adopted family ref
- QEF-E-PROXY
- Full family path
- Super root
- Family id
- QEF-E-MOD
- Label
- Representation & Models
- Root family
- Family id
- QEF-E-EVAL
- Label
- Model Evaluation
- Parent family
- Not specified
- Principle family
- Family id
- QEF-E-PROXY
- Label
- Proxy Validation
- Family precision
- provisional_principle_family
- Review status
- review_required_title_inferred_or_fixture_based
- Human accepted
- False
- Role ref
- P48-45/E2
- Record kind
- active_proposal
- Canonical type supported
- True
- Canonical readiness
- not_assessed_not_approved
P48-45/O1 · Ontological
World mechanic
Targets can redirect team effort toward measured results.
Super rootSystems
Root familySystem Dynamics
Parent familyAdaptive Responses
Principle familyTarget-Driven Adaptation
data/reconciliation/qe48-checkpoint4-resolutions.json
Review status and complete proposal
- Input id
- P48-45
- Title
- What gets measured gets gamed
- Owner ref
- QE-EX-METRIC
- Role id
- O1
- Stack
- Ontological
- Proposed role type
- world_mechanic
- Effective role summary
- Targets can redirect team effort toward measured results.
- Summary source
- Path
- data/reconciliation/qe48-checkpoint4-resolutions.json
- Collection
- rows
- Input id
- P48-45
- Stack
- Ontological
- Role id
- O1
- Authority
- editorial_semantic_proposal
- Legacy summary ref
- data/reconciliation/qe48-checkpoint4-resolutions.json#P48-45/Ontological/O1
- Adopted family ref
- QEF-O-TGT
- Full family path
- Super root
- Family id
- QEF-O-SYS
- Label
- Systems
- Root family
- Family id
- QEF-O-DYN
- Label
- System Dynamics
- Parent family
- Family id
- QEF-O-RESP
- Label
- Adaptive Responses
- Principle family
- Family id
- QEF-O-TGT
- Label
- Target-Driven Adaptation
- Family precision
- provisional_principle_family
- Review status
- review_required_title_inferred_or_fixture_based
- Human accepted
- False
- Role ref
- P48-45/O1
- Record kind
- active_proposal
- Canonical type supported
- True
- Canonical readiness
- not_assessed_not_approved
P48-45/O2 · Ontological
Hidden structure
A proxy can reward behavior that differs from the intended service outcome.
data/reconciliation/qe48-checkpoint4-resolutions.json
Review status and complete proposal
- Input id
- P48-45
- Title
- What gets measured gets gamed
- Owner ref
- QE-EX-METRIC
- Role id
- O2
- Stack
- Ontological
- Proposed role type
- hidden_structure
- Effective role summary
- A proxy can reward behavior that differs from the intended service outcome.
- Summary source
- Path
- data/reconciliation/qe48-checkpoint4-resolutions.json
- Collection
- rows
- Input id
- P48-45
- Stack
- Ontological
- Role id
- O2
- Authority
- editorial_semantic_proposal
- Legacy summary ref
- data/reconciliation/qe48-checkpoint4-resolutions.json#P48-45/Ontological/O2
- Adopted family ref
- QEF-O-SYS
- Full family path
- Super root
- Family id
- QEF-O-SYS
- Label
- Systems
- Root family
- Not specified
- Parent family
- Not specified
- Principle family
- Not specified
- Family precision
- provisional_super_root
- Review status
- r16_structural_family_correction_proposed_pending_source_review
- Human accepted
- False
- Role ref
- P48-45/O2
- Record kind
- active_proposal
- Canonical type supported
- True
- Canonical readiness
- not_assessed_not_approved
Ownership comparisons
- R18C-03 · specialized_mechanism_preserve_multirole_owner
- R18C-04 · within_card_distinct_structural_roles
- R19C-40 · proxy_metric_governance_vs_reward_rule_design
- R19C-43 · administrative_category_consequences_vs_target_gaming
- R19C-63 · failure_vs_corrective_roles_distinct
- R19C-64 · distinct_proxy_validity_and_sampling_methods