QUINTESSENTIALS Proposal intake / P48-23
P48-23
Modularity contains failure
Current proposed roles · editorial proposals, not accepted Card definitions.
Not acceptedConcept identity review
- Input id
- P48-23
- Original title
- Modularity contains failure
- Identity candidate ref
- QE48-C23
- Identity review status
- candidate_distinct_card_identity
- Historical roles recovered
- False
- Accepted identity
- False
Card coverage
Candidate only
Proposed concept boundary: Boundaries between modules can limit propagation of some failures.
Open decision
Specify interfaces, shared dependencies and coordination costs; author design advice separately from the structural claim.
Missing work
- Review concept identity and role ownership before authoring a Card.
- Author role-local scope, logic and required method, diagnostic, objective or action content for the selected functions.
- Record exact inspected sources and transformations, or explicitly review QE editorial synthesis with assertion-level evidence limits.
- Obtain editorial acceptance separately from structural validation.
Complete coverage record
- Input id
- P48-23
- Original title
- Modularity contains failure
- Candidate identity ref
- QE48-C23
- Proposed concept boundary
- Boundaries between modules can limit propagation of some failures.
- Active role refs
- P48-23/O1
- P48-23/D1
- Held role refs
- None recorded
- Authored card ref
- Not specified
- Fixture identity ref
- Not specified
- Related authored card refs
- None recorded
- Ownership case refs
- R19C-42
- R19C-54
- R19C-55
- Coverage status
- candidate_only
- Unresolved decision
- Specify interfaces, shared dependencies and coordination costs; author design advice separately from the structural claim.
- Missing work
- Review concept identity and role ownership before authoring a Card.
- Author role-local scope, logic and required method, diagnostic, objective or action content for the selected functions.
- Record exact inspected sources and transformations, or explicitly review QE editorial synthesis with assertion-level evidence limits.
- Obtain editorial acceptance separately from structural validation.
- Accepted identity
- False
- Evidence status
- title_derived_editorial_proposal_not_verified
P48-23/D1 · Decision
Design implication
Choose modular boundaries when containment and independent changes justify interface costs.
Super rootOptimization & Control
Root familyNot assigned
Parent familyNot assigned
Principle familyNot assigned
data/reconciliation/qe48-checkpoint4-resolutions.json
Review status and complete proposal
- Input id
- P48-23
- Title
- Modularity contains failure
- Owner ref
- QE48-C23
- Role id
- D1
- Stack
- Decision
- Proposed role type
- design_implication
- Effective role summary
- Choose modular boundaries when containment and independent changes justify interface costs.
- Summary source
- Path
- data/reconciliation/qe48-checkpoint4-resolutions.json
- Collection
- rows
- Input id
- P48-23
- Stack
- Decision
- Role id
- D1
- Authority
- editorial_semantic_proposal
- Legacy summary ref
- data/reconciliation/qe48-checkpoint4-resolutions.json#P48-23/Decision/D1
- Adopted family ref
- QEF-D-GOV
- Full family path
- Super root
- Family id
- QEF-D-GOV
- Label
- Optimization & Control
- Root family
- Not specified
- Parent family
- Not specified
- Principle family
- Not specified
- Family precision
- super_root_only_pending_more_specific_review
- Review status
- review_required_title_inferred_or_fixture_based
- Human accepted
- False
- Role ref
- P48-23/D1
- Record kind
- active_proposal
- Canonical type supported
- True
- Canonical readiness
- not_assessed_not_approved
P48-23/O1 · Ontological
World mechanic
Separately controlled modules with effective interfaces can interrupt fault propagation through dependencies, while hidden shared resources or tightly coupled paths can bypass those boundaries.
Super rootSystems
Root familySystem Dynamics
Parent familyConsequence Propagation
Principle familyNot assigned
data/reconciliation/qe48-r12-semantic-repairs.json
Review status and complete proposal
- Input id
- P48-23
- Title
- Modularity contains failure
- Owner ref
- QE48-C23
- Role id
- O1
- Stack
- Ontological
- Proposed role type
- world_mechanic
- Effective role summary
- Separately controlled modules with effective interfaces can interrupt fault propagation through dependencies, while hidden shared resources or tightly coupled paths can bypass those boundaries.
- Summary source
- Path
- data/reconciliation/qe48-r12-semantic-repairs.json
- Collection
- changes
- Input id
- P48-23
- Stack
- Ontological
- Role id
- O1
- Authority
- new_QE_editorial_boundary_repair_not_primary_source
- Legacy summary ref
- data/reconciliation/qe48-checkpoint4-resolutions.json#P48-23/Ontological/O1
- Adopted family ref
- QEF-O-PROP
- Full family path
- Super root
- Family id
- QEF-O-SYS
- Label
- Systems
- Root family
- Family id
- QEF-O-DYN
- Label
- System Dynamics
- Parent family
- Family id
- QEF-O-PROP
- Label
- Consequence Propagation
- Principle family
- Not specified
- Family precision
- provisional_broad_family
- Review status
- r12_semantic_boundary_repair_pending_acceptance
- Human accepted
- False
- Role ref
- P48-23/O1
- Record kind
- active_proposal
- Canonical type supported
- True
- Canonical readiness
- not_assessed_not_approved