{ "corpus_version": "qe-canonical-batch-001-0.1.2", "ontology_version": "qe-ontology-0.1.4", "interpretation_version": "qe-supplied-contributions-0.1.1", "plan_version": "qe-canonical-plan-0.1.0", "authored_card_ids": [ "QE-EX-TRUST", "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "QE-FOLLOW-THROUGH", "QE-RECOGNITION-DESIGN", "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "QE-EX-SECOND", "QE48-C01", "QE48-C03", "QE48-C30" ], "imported_provider_ids": [ "QE-EX-TARGETS" ], "historical_mapping_dispositions": [ { "mapping_id": "MAP-HD6", "state": "superseded_in_current_corpus", "replacement_mapping_refs": [ "MAP-HD-P06-C1" ], "reason": "Use the full row and explicit contribution as current provenance, retaining the old summary and mapping only in the frozen fixture. The reported financing event remains a separate observation." }, { "mapping_id": "MAP-MK4", "state": "superseded_in_current_corpus", "replacement_mapping_refs": [ "MAP-MK-I04-C1" ], "reason": "The current route retains the continuing relationship-design criterion; it does not retrospectively assert that this recommendation is identical to the trust-to-cooperation explanation." } ], "retelling_groups": [ { "source_refs": [ "SRC-HD-SUMMARY", "SRC-HD-TABLE", "SRC-ROW-HD-P06" ], "reason": "Overlapping supplied summaries of the same Home Depot account. Multiple traces are not independent corroboration." }, { "source_refs": [ "SRC-MK-SUPPLIED", "SRC-MK-TABLE", "SRC-ROW-MK-I04" ], "reason": "Overlapping supplied Mary Kay customer-relationship material. The full row is current provenance, not a second independent source." } ], "traces": [ { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-P03", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "plan_id": "B1-RECOGNITION", "disposition": "shared_claim_candidate", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-P03", "expression_ref": "X-MK-P03-C2", "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-P03", "source_cells": [ { "column": "How it shows up in the transcript", "text": "Recognition and respect became central to her culture and leadership style.", "archive_locator": { "path": "data/provenance/supplied-tables.txt", "section": "MK-P", "line": 11 } } ], "contribution_basis": "qe_synthesis", "source_limits": "Respect is a related treatment standard, not exhausted by recognition; no universal performance effect is inferred.", "reported_row_locations": [], "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-P03-C2", "observation_ref": null, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-P03-C2", "anchor_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-RECOGNITION-DESIGN", "role_id": "D1" } }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-P04", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "plan_id": "B1-RECOGNITION", "disposition": "distinct_role_candidate", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-P04", "expression_ref": "X-MK-P04-C1", "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-P04", "source_cells": [ { "column": "Core meaning", "text": "Recognition drives performance better than criticism alone.", "archive_locator": { "path": "data/provenance/supplied-tables.txt", "section": "MK-P", "line": 12 } } ], "contribution_basis": "source_paraphrase", "source_limits": "Comparative superiority over criticism is a source assertion, not an established effect.", "reported_row_locations": [], "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-P04-C1", "observation_ref": null, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-P04-C1", "anchor_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-RECOGNITION-DESIGN", "role_id": "O1" } }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-P04", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "plan_id": "B1-RECOGNITION", "disposition": "practice_candidate", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-P04", "expression_ref": "X-MK-P04-C2", "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-P04", "source_cells": [ { "column": "Principle", "text": "Praise people to success", "archive_locator": { "path": "data/provenance/supplied-tables.txt", "section": "MK-P", "line": 12 } }, { "column": "How it shows up in the transcript", "text": "Public praise, pins, rings, prizes, and pink Cadillacs were used to reinforce achievement.", "archive_locator": { "path": "data/provenance/supplied-tables.txt", "section": "MK-P", "line": 12 } } ], "contribution_basis": "source_paraphrase", "source_limits": "Pins, rings, prizes and cars are examples, not separate families or a universal reward prescription.", "reported_row_locations": [], "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-P04-C2", "observation_ref": null, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-P04-C2", "anchor_ref": "N-MK-P04-C2", "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-RECOGNITION-DESIGN", "role_id": "D1" } }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-P07", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "plan_id": "B1-FOLLOW", "disposition": "shared_claim_candidate", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-P07", "expression_ref": "X-MK-P07-C1", "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-P07", "source_cells": [ { "column": "Principle", "text": "Be a follow-through person", "archive_locator": { "path": "data/provenance/supplied-tables.txt", "section": "MK-P", "line": 15 } }, { "column": "Core meaning", "text": "Reliability and doing what you say matter enormously.", "archive_locator": { "path": "data/provenance/supplied-tables.txt", "section": "MK-P", "line": 15 } } ], "contribution_basis": "source_paraphrase", "source_limits": "Unfulfillable commitments may require explicit renegotiation; this is not a rule of unlimited persistence.", "reported_row_locations": [], "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-P07-C1", "observation_ref": null, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-P07-C1", "anchor_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-FOLLOW-THROUGH", "role_id": "D1" } }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-P07", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "plan_id": "B1-FOLLOW", "disposition": "practice_candidate", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-P07", "expression_ref": "X-MK-P07-C2", "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-P07", "source_cells": [ { "column": "How it shows up in the transcript", "text": "She emphasized returning calls, answering letters, follow-up lists, and customer follow-through.", "archive_locator": { "path": "data/provenance/supplied-tables.txt", "section": "MK-P", "line": 15 } } ], "contribution_basis": "source_paraphrase", "source_limits": "The account does not specify service deadlines or a complete follow-up system.", "reported_row_locations": [], "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-P07-C2", "observation_ref": null, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-P07-C2", "anchor_ref": "N-MK-P07-C2", "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-FOLLOW-THROUGH", "role_id": "D1" } }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-P20", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "plan_id": "B1-REWARDS", "disposition": "shared_claim_candidate", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-P20", "expression_ref": "X-MK-P20-C2", "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-P20", "source_cells": [ { "column": "How it shows up in the transcript", "text": "She repeatedly identified broken incentives and redesigned the system around them.", "archive_locator": { "path": "data/provenance/supplied-tables.txt", "section": "MK-P", "line": 28 } } ], "contribution_basis": "qe_synthesis", "source_limits": "The conditional intervention is inferred from the example; the actual reward rules are unspecified.", "reported_row_locations": [], "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-P20-C2", "observation_ref": null, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-P20-C2", "anchor_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "role_id": "D1" } }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I03", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "plan_id": "B1-REWARDS", "disposition": "shared_claim_candidate", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-I03", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I03-C1", "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I03", "source_cells": [ { "column": "Idea", "text": "Design incentives carefully", "archive_locator": { "path": "data/provenance/supplied-tables.txt", "section": "MK-I", "line": 39 } } ], "contribution_basis": "source_paraphrase", "source_limits": "The title supplies no specific reward formula or implementation.", "reported_row_locations": [], "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-I03-C1", "observation_ref": null, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-I03-C1", "anchor_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "role_id": "D1" } }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I03", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "plan_id": "B1-REWARDS", "disposition": "distinct_role_candidate", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-I03", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I03-C2", "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I03", "source_cells": [ { "column": "Meaning", "text": "Systems produce behavior; wrong incentives destroy performance.", "archive_locator": { "path": "data/provenance/supplied-tables.txt", "section": "MK-I", "line": 39 } } ], "contribution_basis": "source_paraphrase", "source_limits": "Incentives do not explain every motive; destruction is not treated as inevitable.", "reported_row_locations": [], "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-I03-C2", "observation_ref": null, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-I03-C2", "anchor_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "role_id": "O1" } }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I03", "contribution_id": "C3" }, "plan_id": "B1-REWARDS", "disposition": "case_context", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-I03", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I03-C3", "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I03", "source_cells": [ { "column": "Evidence from transcript", "text": "She inverted broken incentive structures from prior employers.", "archive_locator": { "path": "data/provenance/supplied-tables.txt", "section": "MK-I", "line": 39 } } ], "contribution_basis": "source_paraphrase", "source_limits": "The prior and replacement incentive rules are not given.", "reported_row_locations": [], "mapping_ref": null, "observation_ref": { "kind": "observation", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "observation_id": "OBS-MK-I03-C3" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-CASE-MK-I03-C3", "anchor_ref": "N-MK-I03-C3", "assembly_role_ref": null }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I04", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "plan_id": "B1-TRUST", "disposition": "shared_claim_candidate", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-I04", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I04-C1", "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I04", "source_cells": [ { "column": "Idea", "text": "Treat customers as relationships, not transactions", "archive_locator": { "path": "data/provenance/supplied-tables.txt", "section": "MK-I", "line": 40 } }, { "column": "Meaning", "text": "Long-term trust matters more than one-off selling.", "archive_locator": { "path": "data/provenance/supplied-tables.txt", "section": "MK-I", "line": 40 } } ], "contribution_basis": "source_paraphrase", "source_limits": "Repeat relationships are not always the right commercial objective.", "reported_row_locations": [], "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-I04-C1", "observation_ref": null, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-I04-C1", "anchor_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-TRUST", "role_id": "D1" } }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I04", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "plan_id": "B1-TRUST", "disposition": "practice_candidate", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-I04", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I04-C2", "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I04", "source_cells": [ { "column": "Evidence from transcript", "text": "Her regular follow-up calls and service mindset drove repeat business.", "archive_locator": { "path": "data/provenance/supplied-tables.txt", "section": "MK-I", "line": 40 } } ], "contribution_basis": "source_paraphrase", "source_limits": "The claimed repeat-business effect is not independently established; no frequency is prescribed.", "reported_row_locations": [], "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-I04-C2", "observation_ref": null, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-I04-C2", "anchor_ref": "N-MK-I04-C2", "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-TRUST", "role_id": "D1" } }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I06", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "plan_id": "B1-RECOGNITION", "disposition": "shared_claim_candidate", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-I06", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I06-C1", "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I06", "source_cells": [ { "column": "Idea", "text": "Recognition should be meaningful and visible", "archive_locator": { "path": "data/provenance/supplied-tables.txt", "section": "MK-I", "line": 42 } }, { "column": "Evidence from transcript", "text": "Rings, prizes, conventions, and pink Cadillacs were intentionally symbolic.", "archive_locator": { "path": "data/provenance/supplied-tables.txt", "section": "MK-I", "line": 42 } } ], "contribution_basis": "source_paraphrase", "source_limits": "Rings, cars and ceremonies are illustrative choices, not necessary components.", "reported_row_locations": [], "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-I06-C1", "observation_ref": null, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-I06-C1", "anchor_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-RECOGNITION-DESIGN", "role_id": "D1" } }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I06", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "plan_id": "B1-RECOGNITION", "disposition": "distinct_role_candidate", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-I06", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I06-C2", "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I06", "source_cells": [ { "column": "Meaning", "text": "Status-linked rewards can motivate more than cash alone.", "archive_locator": { "path": "data/provenance/supplied-tables.txt", "section": "MK-I", "line": 42 } } ], "contribution_basis": "source_paraphrase", "source_limits": "The claimed advantage over cash is not established for every person or context.", "reported_row_locations": [], "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-I06-C2", "observation_ref": null, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-I06-C2", "anchor_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-RECOGNITION-DESIGN", "role_id": "O1" } }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I07", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "plan_id": "B1-REWARDS", "disposition": "practice_candidate", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-I07", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I07-C1", "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I07", "source_cells": [ { "column": "Idea", "text": "Meritocracy beats politics", "archive_locator": { "path": "data/provenance/supplied-tables.txt", "section": "MK-I", "line": 43 } }, { "column": "Meaning", "text": "Advancement should come from clear performance, not status or connections.", "archive_locator": { "path": "data/provenance/supplied-tables.txt", "section": "MK-I", "line": 43 } } ], "contribution_basis": "source_paraphrase", "source_limits": "Clear performance criteria may still be incomplete or biased.", "reported_row_locations": [], "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-I07-C1", "observation_ref": null, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-I07-C1", "anchor_ref": "N-MK-I07-C1", "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "role_id": "D1" } }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I07", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "plan_id": "B1-REWARDS", "disposition": "practice_candidate", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-I07", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I07-C2", "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I07", "source_cells": [ { "column": "Evidence from transcript", "text": "Promotions and advancement were based on sales results, not gender or background.", "archive_locator": { "path": "data/provenance/supplied-tables.txt", "section": "MK-I", "line": 43 } } ], "contribution_basis": "source_paraphrase", "source_limits": "Sales are not a complete measure of merit; fairness and the claimed historical practice remain unverified.", "reported_row_locations": [], "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-I07-C2", "observation_ref": null, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-I07-C2", "anchor_ref": "N-MK-I07-C2", "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "role_id": "D1" } }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I09", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "plan_id": "B1-REWARDS", "disposition": "distinct_role_candidate", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-I09", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I09-C1", "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I09", "source_cells": [ { "column": "Idea", "text": "Cooperation beats zero-sum competition", "archive_locator": { "path": "data/provenance/supplied-tables.txt", "section": "MK-I", "line": 45 } }, { "column": "Meaning", "text": "Let multiple people win so peers help one another.", "archive_locator": { "path": "data/provenance/supplied-tables.txt", "section": "MK-I", "line": 45 } } ], "contribution_basis": "source_paraphrase", "source_limits": "Cooperation is a proposed response, not guaranteed by nonexclusive awards.", "reported_row_locations": [], "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-I09-C1", "observation_ref": null, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-I09-C1", "anchor_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "role_id": "O1" } }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I09", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "plan_id": "B1-REWARDS", "disposition": "practice_candidate", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-I09", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I09-C2", "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I09", "source_cells": [ { "column": "Evidence from transcript", "text": "Her competitions allowed all who hit targets to win, not just one person.", "archive_locator": { "path": "data/provenance/supplied-tables.txt", "section": "MK-I", "line": 45 } } ], "contribution_basis": "source_paraphrase", "source_limits": "Target quality and possible gaming still need review; this is not equal rewards regardless of contribution.", "reported_row_locations": [], "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-I09-C2", "observation_ref": null, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-I09-C2", "anchor_ref": "N-MK-I09-C2", "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "role_id": "D1" } }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I11", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "plan_id": "B1-CUSTOMER", "disposition": "practice_candidate", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-I11", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I11-C1", "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I11", "source_cells": [ { "column": "Idea", "text": "Sell complete solutions, not fragmented pieces", "archive_locator": { "path": "data/provenance/supplied-tables.txt", "section": "MK-I", "line": 47 } }, { "column": "Meaning", "text": "Partial use can reduce customer results and damage trust.", "archive_locator": { "path": "data/provenance/supplied-tables.txt", "section": "MK-I", "line": 47 } } ], "contribution_basis": "source_paraphrase", "source_limits": "This does not justify bundling products that customers do not need.", "reported_row_locations": [], "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-I11-C1", "observation_ref": null, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-I11-C1", "anchor_ref": "N-MK-I11-C1", "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "role_id": "D1" } }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I11", "contribution_id": "C3" }, "plan_id": "B1-CUSTOMER", "disposition": "practice_candidate", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-I11", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I11-C3", "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I11", "source_cells": [ { "column": "Evidence from transcript", "text": "She stopped breaking up the skincare set because it hurt outcomes and referrals.", "archive_locator": { "path": "data/provenance/supplied-tables.txt", "section": "MK-I", "line": 47 } } ], "contribution_basis": "source_paraphrase", "source_limits": "The reported outcome/referral link does not prove all partial purchases are ineffective.", "reported_row_locations": [], "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-I11-C3", "observation_ref": null, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-I11-C3", "anchor_ref": "N-MK-I11-C3", "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "role_id": "D1" } }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I13", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "plan_id": "B1-REWARDS", "disposition": "shared_claim_candidate", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-I13", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I13-C1", "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I13", "source_cells": [ { "column": "Idea", "text": "Culture is what you systematically reward", "archive_locator": { "path": "data/provenance/supplied-tables.txt", "section": "MK-I", "line": 49 } }, { "column": "Meaning", "text": "Values only matter if embedded in systems and incentives.", "archive_locator": { "path": "data/provenance/supplied-tables.txt", "section": "MK-I", "line": 49 } } ], "contribution_basis": "qe_synthesis", "source_limits": "The normative alignment instruction is QE synthesis; values can matter through channels other than incentives.", "reported_row_locations": [], "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-I13-C1", "observation_ref": null, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-I13-C1", "anchor_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "role_id": "D1" } }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "HD-P06", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "plan_id": "B1-TRUST", "disposition": "shared_claim_candidate", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-HD-P06", "expression_ref": "X-HD-P06-C1", "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P06", "source_cells": [ { "column": "Principle", "text": "Businesses are built on relationships and trust", "archive_locator": { "path": "data/provenance/supplied-tables.txt", "section": "HD-P", "line": 60 } }, { "column": "Core meaning", "text": "Long-term success comes from openness, credibility, and real relationships.", "archive_locator": { "path": "data/provenance/supplied-tables.txt", "section": "HD-P", "line": 60 } } ], "contribution_basis": "source_paraphrase", "source_limits": "The broad success claim is narrowed; trust is not the only cause of business outcomes.", "reported_row_locations": [ "12:34–13:26", "28:44–30:21" ], "mapping_ref": "MAP-HD-P06-C1", "observation_ref": null, "assessment_ref": "EV-HD-P06-C1", "anchor_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-TRUST", "role_id": "O1" } }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "HD-P06", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "plan_id": "B1-TRUST", "disposition": "practice_candidate", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-HD-P06", "expression_ref": "X-HD-P06-C2", "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P06", "source_cells": [ { "column": "How it shows up in the transcript", "text": "Bernie tells banker Rip Fleming everything transparently; Rip later risks his own career to get them financed because he trusts the people, not just the numbers.", "archive_locator": { "path": "data/provenance/supplied-tables.txt", "section": "HD-P", "line": 60 } } ], "contribution_basis": "qe_synthesis", "source_limits": "This generalization comes from the account; candor neither guarantees credit nor replaces controls.", "reported_row_locations": [ "12:34–13:26", "28:44–30:21" ], "mapping_ref": "MAP-HD-P06-C2", "observation_ref": null, "assessment_ref": "EV-HD-P06-C2", "anchor_ref": "N-HD-P06-C2", "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-TRUST", "role_id": "D1" } }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "HD-P06", "contribution_id": "C3" }, "plan_id": "B1-TRUST", "disposition": "case_context", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-HD-P06", "expression_ref": "X-HD-P06-C3", "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P06", "source_cells": [ { "column": "How it shows up in the transcript", "text": "Bernie tells banker Rip Fleming everything transparently; Rip later risks his own career to get them financed because he trusts the people, not just the numbers.", "archive_locator": { "path": "data/provenance/supplied-tables.txt", "section": "HD-P", "line": 60 } } ], "contribution_basis": "source_paraphrase", "source_limits": "The banker's motive and counterfactual financing outcome were not independently verified.", "reported_row_locations": [ "12:34–13:26", "28:44–30:21" ], "mapping_ref": null, "observation_ref": { "kind": "observation", "card_id": "QE-EX-TRUST", "observation_id": "OBS-HD-P06-C3" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-CASE-HD-P06-C3", "anchor_ref": "N-HD-P06-C3", "assembly_role_ref": null }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "HD-P07", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "plan_id": "B1-CUSTOMER", "disposition": "shared_claim_candidate", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-HD-P07", "expression_ref": "X-HD-P07-C1", "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P07", "source_cells": [ { "column": "Principle", "text": "Serve the customer or the business dies", "archive_locator": { "path": "data/provenance/supplied-tables.txt", "section": "HD-P", "line": 61 } }, { "column": "Core meaning", "text": "The moment a company starts serving itself instead of the customer, decline begins.", "archive_locator": { "path": "data/provenance/supplied-tables.txt", "section": "HD-P", "line": 61 } } ], "contribution_basis": "qe_synthesis", "source_limits": "The instruction is QE synthesis of the decline claim; customer service alone does not assure survival.", "reported_row_locations": [ "07:44–08:08", "55:03–55:20" ], "mapping_ref": "MAP-HD-P07-C1", "observation_ref": null, "assessment_ref": "EV-HD-P07-C1", "anchor_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "role_id": "D1" } }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "HD-P07", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "plan_id": "B1-CUSTOMER", "disposition": "distinct_role_candidate", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-HD-P07", "expression_ref": "X-HD-P07-C2", "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P07", "source_cells": [ { "column": "How it shows up in the transcript", "text": "Bernie’s lesson from Two Guys: when leaders focus on careers over customers, customers vanish and the company collapses.", "archive_locator": { "path": "data/provenance/supplied-tables.txt", "section": "HD-P", "line": 61 } } ], "contribution_basis": "source_paraphrase", "source_limits": "The Two Guys causal attribution and collapse sequence are reported, not a verified sufficient explanation.", "reported_row_locations": [ "07:44–08:08", "55:03–55:20" ], "mapping_ref": "MAP-HD-P07-C2", "observation_ref": null, "assessment_ref": "EV-HD-P07-C2", "anchor_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "role_id": "O1" } }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "HD-P08", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "plan_id": "B1-CUSTOMER", "disposition": "shared_claim_candidate", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-HD-P08", "expression_ref": "X-HD-P08-C1", "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P08", "source_cells": [ { "column": "Principle", "text": "Customer service is a philosophy, not a department", "archive_locator": { "path": "data/provenance/supplied-tables.txt", "section": "HD-P", "line": 62 } }, { "column": "Core meaning", "text": "Everyone should do whatever it takes to solve the customer’s problem.", "archive_locator": { "path": "data/provenance/supplied-tables.txt", "section": "HD-P", "line": 62 } } ], "contribution_basis": "source_paraphrase", "source_limits": "Whatever it takes remains subject to safety, obligations, cost and feasibility.", "reported_row_locations": [ "35:30–38:24", "53:07–53:23" ], "mapping_ref": "MAP-HD-P08-C1", "observation_ref": null, "assessment_ref": "EV-HD-P08-C1", "anchor_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "role_id": "D1" } }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "HD-P08", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "plan_id": "B1-CUSTOMER", "disposition": "practice_candidate", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-HD-P08", "expression_ref": "X-HD-P08-C2", "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P08", "source_cells": [ { "column": "How it shows up in the transcript", "text": "Bernie chases customers into the parking lot, buys missing products from competitors, and personally delivers them; associates do similarly extraordinary things.", "archive_locator": { "path": "data/provenance/supplied-tables.txt", "section": "HD-P", "line": 62 } } ], "contribution_basis": "source_paraphrase", "source_limits": "The report supplies no authority limits, repeatability or economics for this practice.", "reported_row_locations": [ "35:30–38:24", "53:07–53:23" ], "mapping_ref": "MAP-HD-P08-C2", "observation_ref": null, "assessment_ref": "EV-HD-P08-C2", "anchor_ref": "N-HD-P08-C2", "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "role_id": "D1" } }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "HD-P09", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "plan_id": "B1-TRUST", "disposition": "shared_claim_candidate", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-HD-P09", "expression_ref": "X-HD-P09-C1", "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P09", "source_cells": [ { "column": "Principle", "text": "Every customer is “on loan”", "archive_locator": { "path": "data/provenance/supplied-tables.txt", "section": "HD-P", "line": 63 } }, { "column": "Core meaning", "text": "You never permanently own customer loyalty; you must re-earn it every day.", "archive_locator": { "path": "data/provenance/supplied-tables.txt", "section": "HD-P", "line": 63 } } ], "contribution_basis": "source_paraphrase", "source_limits": "The source does not supply a service frequency or a guarantee of retention.", "reported_row_locations": [ "52:59–53:23" ], "mapping_ref": "MAP-HD-P09-C1", "observation_ref": null, "assessment_ref": "EV-HD-P09-C1", "anchor_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-TRUST", "role_id": "D1" } }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "HD-P09", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "plan_id": "B1-CUSTOMER", "disposition": "distinct_role_candidate", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-HD-P09", "expression_ref": "X-HD-P09-C2", "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P09", "source_cells": [ { "column": "How it shows up in the transcript", "text": "Bernie says customers choose you today and can choose someone else tomorrow, so trust must be earned in every interaction.", "archive_locator": { "path": "data/provenance/supplied-tables.txt", "section": "HD-P", "line": 63 } } ], "contribution_basis": "source_paraphrase", "source_limits": "Choice can be constrained; no claim that switching is always costless is made.", "reported_row_locations": [ "52:59–53:23" ], "mapping_ref": "MAP-HD-P09-C2", "observation_ref": null, "assessment_ref": "EV-HD-P09-C2", "anchor_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "role_id": "O1" } }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "HD-P10", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "plan_id": "B1-CUSTOMER", "disposition": "shared_claim_candidate", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-HD-P10", "expression_ref": "X-HD-P10-C1", "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P10", "source_cells": [ { "column": "Principle", "text": "Give customers what they value, not retail theater", "archive_locator": { "path": "data/provenance/supplied-tables.txt", "section": "HD-P", "line": 64 } }, { "column": "Core meaning", "text": "Cut costs on appearances that customers do not care about; invest in price, assortment, and knowledgeable help.", "archive_locator": { "path": "data/provenance/supplied-tables.txt", "section": "HD-P", "line": 64 } } ], "contribution_basis": "source_paraphrase", "source_limits": "Appearances may matter in other settings; the criterion requires actual customer understanding.", "reported_row_locations": [ "33:13–35:23", "37:54–38:43" ], "mapping_ref": "MAP-HD-P10-C1", "observation_ref": null, "assessment_ref": "EV-HD-P10-C1", "anchor_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "role_id": "D1" } }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "HD-P10", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "plan_id": "B1-CUSTOMER", "disposition": "practice_candidate", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-HD-P10", "expression_ref": "X-HD-P10-C2", "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P10", "source_cells": [ { "column": "How it shows up in the transcript", "text": "The warehouse look is deliberate: scuffed floors, visible action, no over-facing, no decorative polish; customer “bill of rights” centers on assortment, price, availability, and trained associates.", "archive_locator": { "path": "data/provenance/supplied-tables.txt", "section": "HD-P", "line": 64 } } ], "contribution_basis": "source_paraphrase", "source_limits": "Scuffed floors and limited decorative polish are context, not requirements for every retailer.", "reported_row_locations": [ "33:13–35:23", "37:54–38:43" ], "mapping_ref": "MAP-HD-P10-C2", "observation_ref": null, "assessment_ref": "EV-HD-P10-C2", "anchor_ref": "N-HD-P10-C2", "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "role_id": "D1" } }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "HD-P11", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "plan_id": "B1-CUSTOMER", "disposition": "practice_candidate", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-HD-P11", "expression_ref": "X-HD-P11-C1", "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P11", "source_cells": [ { "column": "Principle", "text": "Low prices should be structural, not promotional theater", "archive_locator": { "path": "data/provenance/supplied-tables.txt", "section": "HD-P", "line": 65 } }, { "column": "Core meaning", "text": "Stable, trusted value beats short-lived sales spikes.", "archive_locator": { "path": "data/provenance/supplied-tables.txt", "section": "HD-P", "line": 65 } } ], "contribution_basis": "source_paraphrase", "source_limits": "The comparative advantage is context-dependent, not a universally established result.", "reported_row_locations": [ "42:22–45:18" ], "mapping_ref": "MAP-HD-P11-C1", "observation_ref": null, "assessment_ref": "EV-HD-P11-C1", "anchor_ref": "N-HD-P11-C1", "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "role_id": "D1" } }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "HD-P11", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "plan_id": "B1-CUSTOMER", "disposition": "practice_candidate", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-HD-P11", "expression_ref": "X-HD-P11-C2", "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P11", "source_cells": [ { "column": "How it shows up in the transcript", "text": "Home Depot abandons promotion-driven spikes for everyday low pricing after learning from Sam Walton and Saul Price.", "archive_locator": { "path": "data/provenance/supplied-tables.txt", "section": "HD-P", "line": 65 } } ], "contribution_basis": "source_paraphrase", "source_limits": "Learning from other retailers is reported; no unit economics or structural cost advantage is supplied.", "reported_row_locations": [ "42:22–45:18" ], "mapping_ref": "MAP-HD-P11-C2", "observation_ref": null, "assessment_ref": "EV-HD-P11-C2", "anchor_ref": "N-HD-P11-C2", "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "role_id": "D1" } }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "HD-P13", "contribution_id": "C3" }, "plan_id": "B1-RECOGNITION", "disposition": "practice_candidate", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-HD-P13", "expression_ref": "X-HD-P13-C3", "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P13", "source_cells": [ { "column": "How it shows up in the transcript", "text": "Stock options make thousands of regular employees wealthy; Olympic rewards go heavily to hourly associates; the message is that orange aprons are the company.", "archive_locator": { "path": "data/provenance/supplied-tables.txt", "section": "HD-P", "line": 67 } } ], "contribution_basis": "qe_synthesis", "source_limits": "Recognition is inferred from the reward example; eligibility rules and effects on motivation are unknown.", "reported_row_locations": [ "01:23–01:39", "46:34–47:49", "52:35–52:42" ], "mapping_ref": "MAP-HD-P13-C3", "observation_ref": null, "assessment_ref": "EV-HD-P13-C3", "anchor_ref": "N-HD-P13-C3", "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-RECOGNITION-DESIGN", "role_id": "D1" } } ], "limitations": [ "Six authored card identities plus one imported provider; seven resolved records is not seven newly authored cards.", "No current empirical verification. Provisional authoring completion is distinct from acceptance of every claim.", "Full readable views and twenty hypothetical entry-condition examples are provided by the separate review layer. V01-V04 procedure, validation and export repairs remain in place. W01/W02 add attachment ownership and report clarity without expanding the six-card scope.", "Assembly role hints do not change whole-card normalization targets. Case reports have no generic normalization mapping." ], "attachment_accounting": { "status": "matched", "policy": "definition_only_inputs_and_exact_import", "generated_records": [ { "card_id": "QE-RECOGNITION-DESIGN", "container": "evidence_assessments", "record_id": "EV-MK-P03-C2", "origin": "selected_contribution", "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-P03", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-P03", "expression_ref": "X-MK-P03-C2" }, { "card_id": "QE-RECOGNITION-DESIGN", "container": "evidence_assessments", "record_id": "EV-MK-P04-C1", "origin": "selected_contribution", "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-P04", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-P04", "expression_ref": "X-MK-P04-C1" }, { "card_id": "QE-RECOGNITION-DESIGN", "container": "evidence_assessments", "record_id": "EV-MK-P04-C2", "origin": "selected_contribution", "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-P04", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-P04", "expression_ref": "X-MK-P04-C2" }, { "card_id": "QE-RECOGNITION-DESIGN", "container": "narrative_anchors", "record_id": "N-MK-P04-C2", "origin": "selected_contribution", "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-P04", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-P04", "expression_ref": "X-MK-P04-C2" }, { "card_id": "QE-FOLLOW-THROUGH", "container": "evidence_assessments", "record_id": "EV-MK-P07-C1", "origin": "selected_contribution", "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-P07", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-P07", "expression_ref": "X-MK-P07-C1" }, { "card_id": "QE-FOLLOW-THROUGH", "container": "evidence_assessments", "record_id": "EV-MK-P07-C2", "origin": "selected_contribution", "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-P07", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-P07", "expression_ref": "X-MK-P07-C2" }, { "card_id": "QE-FOLLOW-THROUGH", "container": "narrative_anchors", "record_id": "N-MK-P07-C2", "origin": "selected_contribution", "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-P07", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-P07", "expression_ref": "X-MK-P07-C2" }, { "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "container": "evidence_assessments", "record_id": "EV-MK-P20-C2", "origin": "selected_contribution", "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-P20", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-P20", "expression_ref": "X-MK-P20-C2" }, { "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "container": "evidence_assessments", "record_id": "EV-MK-I03-C1", "origin": "selected_contribution", "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I03", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I03", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I03-C1" }, { "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "container": "evidence_assessments", "record_id": "EV-MK-I03-C2", "origin": "selected_contribution", "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I03", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I03", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I03-C2" }, { "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "container": "evidence_assessments", "record_id": "EV-CASE-MK-I03-C3", "origin": "selected_contribution", "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I03", "contribution_id": "C3" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I03", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I03-C3" }, { "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "container": "case_observations", "record_id": "OBS-MK-I03-C3", "origin": "selected_contribution", "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I03", "contribution_id": "C3" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I03", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I03-C3" }, { "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "container": "narrative_anchors", "record_id": "N-MK-I03-C3", "origin": "selected_contribution", "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I03", "contribution_id": "C3" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I03", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I03-C3" }, { "card_id": "QE-EX-TRUST", "container": "evidence_assessments", "record_id": "EV-MK-I04-C1", "origin": "selected_contribution", "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I04", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I04", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I04-C1" }, { "card_id": "QE-EX-TRUST", "container": "evidence_assessments", "record_id": "EV-MK-I04-C2", "origin": "selected_contribution", "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I04", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I04", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I04-C2" }, { "card_id": "QE-EX-TRUST", "container": "narrative_anchors", "record_id": "N-MK-I04-C2", "origin": "selected_contribution", "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I04", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I04", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I04-C2" }, { "card_id": "QE-RECOGNITION-DESIGN", "container": "evidence_assessments", "record_id": "EV-MK-I06-C1", "origin": "selected_contribution", "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I06", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I06", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I06-C1" }, { "card_id": "QE-RECOGNITION-DESIGN", "container": "evidence_assessments", "record_id": "EV-MK-I06-C2", "origin": "selected_contribution", "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I06", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I06", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I06-C2" }, { "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "container": "evidence_assessments", "record_id": "EV-MK-I07-C1", "origin": "selected_contribution", "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I07", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I07", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I07-C1" }, { "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "container": "narrative_anchors", "record_id": "N-MK-I07-C1", "origin": "selected_contribution", "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I07", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I07", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I07-C1" }, { "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "container": "evidence_assessments", "record_id": "EV-MK-I07-C2", "origin": "selected_contribution", "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I07", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I07", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I07-C2" }, { "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "container": "narrative_anchors", "record_id": "N-MK-I07-C2", "origin": "selected_contribution", "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I07", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I07", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I07-C2" }, { "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "container": "evidence_assessments", "record_id": "EV-MK-I09-C1", "origin": "selected_contribution", "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I09", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I09", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I09-C1" }, { "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "container": "evidence_assessments", "record_id": "EV-MK-I09-C2", "origin": "selected_contribution", "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I09", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I09", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I09-C2" }, { "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "container": "narrative_anchors", "record_id": "N-MK-I09-C2", "origin": "selected_contribution", "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I09", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I09", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I09-C2" }, { "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "container": "evidence_assessments", "record_id": "EV-MK-I11-C1", "origin": "selected_contribution", "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I11", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I11", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I11-C1" }, { "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "container": "narrative_anchors", "record_id": "N-MK-I11-C1", "origin": "selected_contribution", "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I11", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I11", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I11-C1" }, { "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "container": "evidence_assessments", "record_id": "EV-MK-I11-C3", "origin": "selected_contribution", "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I11", "contribution_id": "C3" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I11", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I11-C3" }, { "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "container": "narrative_anchors", "record_id": "N-MK-I11-C3", "origin": "selected_contribution", "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I11", "contribution_id": "C3" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I11", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I11-C3" }, { "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "container": "evidence_assessments", "record_id": "EV-MK-I13-C1", "origin": "selected_contribution", "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I13", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I13", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I13-C1" }, { "card_id": "QE-EX-TRUST", "container": "evidence_assessments", "record_id": "EV-HD-P06-C1", "origin": "selected_contribution", "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "HD-P06", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P06", "expression_ref": "X-HD-P06-C1" }, { "card_id": "QE-EX-TRUST", "container": "evidence_assessments", "record_id": "EV-HD-P06-C2", "origin": "selected_contribution", "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "HD-P06", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P06", "expression_ref": "X-HD-P06-C2" }, { "card_id": "QE-EX-TRUST", "container": "narrative_anchors", "record_id": "N-HD-P06-C2", "origin": "selected_contribution", "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "HD-P06", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P06", "expression_ref": "X-HD-P06-C2", "summary_origin": { "path": "data/canonical/practice-anchor-reports.json", "source_column": "How it shows up in the transcript", "basis": "qe_paraphrase_of_supplied_report" } }, { "card_id": "QE-EX-TRUST", "container": "evidence_assessments", "record_id": "EV-CASE-HD-P06-C3", "origin": "selected_contribution", "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "HD-P06", "contribution_id": "C3" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P06", "expression_ref": "X-HD-P06-C3" }, { "card_id": "QE-EX-TRUST", "container": "case_observations", "record_id": "OBS-HD-P06-C3", "origin": "selected_contribution", "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "HD-P06", "contribution_id": "C3" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P06", "expression_ref": "X-HD-P06-C3" }, { "card_id": "QE-EX-TRUST", "container": "narrative_anchors", "record_id": "N-HD-P06-C3", "origin": "selected_contribution", "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "HD-P06", "contribution_id": "C3" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P06", "expression_ref": "X-HD-P06-C3" }, { "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "container": "evidence_assessments", "record_id": "EV-HD-P07-C1", "origin": "selected_contribution", "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "HD-P07", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P07", "expression_ref": "X-HD-P07-C1" }, { "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "container": "evidence_assessments", "record_id": "EV-HD-P07-C2", "origin": "selected_contribution", "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "HD-P07", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P07", "expression_ref": "X-HD-P07-C2" }, { "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "container": "evidence_assessments", "record_id": "EV-HD-P08-C1", "origin": "selected_contribution", "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "HD-P08", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P08", "expression_ref": "X-HD-P08-C1" }, { "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "container": "evidence_assessments", "record_id": "EV-HD-P08-C2", "origin": "selected_contribution", "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "HD-P08", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P08", "expression_ref": "X-HD-P08-C2" }, { "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "container": "narrative_anchors", "record_id": "N-HD-P08-C2", "origin": "selected_contribution", "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "HD-P08", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P08", "expression_ref": "X-HD-P08-C2" }, { "card_id": "QE-EX-TRUST", "container": "evidence_assessments", "record_id": "EV-HD-P09-C1", "origin": "selected_contribution", "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "HD-P09", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P09", "expression_ref": "X-HD-P09-C1" }, { "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "container": "evidence_assessments", "record_id": "EV-HD-P09-C2", "origin": "selected_contribution", "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "HD-P09", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P09", "expression_ref": "X-HD-P09-C2" }, { "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "container": "evidence_assessments", "record_id": "EV-HD-P10-C1", "origin": "selected_contribution", "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "HD-P10", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P10", "expression_ref": "X-HD-P10-C1" }, { "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "container": "evidence_assessments", "record_id": "EV-HD-P10-C2", "origin": "selected_contribution", "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "HD-P10", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P10", "expression_ref": "X-HD-P10-C2" }, { "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "container": "narrative_anchors", "record_id": "N-HD-P10-C2", "origin": "selected_contribution", "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "HD-P10", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P10", "expression_ref": "X-HD-P10-C2" }, { "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "container": "evidence_assessments", "record_id": "EV-HD-P11-C1", "origin": "selected_contribution", "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "HD-P11", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P11", "expression_ref": "X-HD-P11-C1" }, { "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "container": "narrative_anchors", "record_id": "N-HD-P11-C1", "origin": "selected_contribution", "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "HD-P11", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P11", "expression_ref": "X-HD-P11-C1" }, { "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "container": "evidence_assessments", "record_id": "EV-HD-P11-C2", "origin": "selected_contribution", "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "HD-P11", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P11", "expression_ref": "X-HD-P11-C2" }, { "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "container": "narrative_anchors", "record_id": "N-HD-P11-C2", "origin": "selected_contribution", "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "HD-P11", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P11", "expression_ref": "X-HD-P11-C2" }, { "card_id": "QE-RECOGNITION-DESIGN", "container": "evidence_assessments", "record_id": "EV-HD-P13-C3", "origin": "selected_contribution", "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "HD-P13", "contribution_id": "C3" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P13", "expression_ref": "X-HD-P13-C3" }, { "card_id": "QE-RECOGNITION-DESIGN", "container": "narrative_anchors", "record_id": "N-HD-P13-C3", "origin": "selected_contribution", "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "HD-P13", "contribution_id": "C3" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P13", "expression_ref": "X-HD-P13-C3", "summary_origin": { "path": "data/canonical/practice-anchor-reports.json", "source_column": "How it shows up in the transcript", "basis": "qe_paraphrase_of_supplied_report" } } ], "source_reference_origins": [ { "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P07", "contribution_refs": [ { "item_id": "HD-P07", "contribution_id": "C1" }, { "item_id": "HD-P07", "contribution_id": "C2" } ] }, { "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P08", "contribution_refs": [ { "item_id": "HD-P08", "contribution_id": "C1" }, { "item_id": "HD-P08", "contribution_id": "C2" } ] }, { "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P09", "contribution_refs": [ { "item_id": "HD-P09", "contribution_id": "C2" } ] }, { "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P10", "contribution_refs": [ { "item_id": "HD-P10", "contribution_id": "C1" }, { "item_id": "HD-P10", "contribution_id": "C2" } ] }, { "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P11", "contribution_refs": [ { "item_id": "HD-P11", "contribution_id": "C1" }, { "item_id": "HD-P11", "contribution_id": "C2" } ] }, { "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I11", "contribution_refs": [ { "item_id": "MK-I11", "contribution_id": "C1" }, { "item_id": "MK-I11", "contribution_id": "C3" } ] }, { "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I03", "contribution_refs": [ { "item_id": "MK-I03", "contribution_id": "C1" }, { "item_id": "MK-I03", "contribution_id": "C2" }, { "item_id": "MK-I03", "contribution_id": "C3" } ] }, { "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I07", "contribution_refs": [ { "item_id": "MK-I07", "contribution_id": "C1" }, { "item_id": "MK-I07", "contribution_id": "C2" } ] }, { "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I09", "contribution_refs": [ { "item_id": "MK-I09", "contribution_id": "C1" }, { "item_id": "MK-I09", "contribution_id": "C2" } ] }, { "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I13", "contribution_refs": [ { "item_id": "MK-I13", "contribution_id": "C1" } ] }, { "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-P20", "contribution_refs": [ { "item_id": "MK-P20", "contribution_id": "C2" } ] }, { "card_id": "QE-EX-TRUST", "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P06", "contribution_refs": [ { "item_id": "HD-P06", "contribution_id": "C1" }, { "item_id": "HD-P06", "contribution_id": "C2" }, { "item_id": "HD-P06", "contribution_id": "C3" } ] }, { "card_id": "QE-EX-TRUST", "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P09", "contribution_refs": [ { "item_id": "HD-P09", "contribution_id": "C1" } ] }, { "card_id": "QE-EX-TRUST", "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I04", "contribution_refs": [ { "item_id": "MK-I04", "contribution_id": "C1" }, { "item_id": "MK-I04", "contribution_id": "C2" } ] }, { "card_id": "QE-FOLLOW-THROUGH", "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-P07", "contribution_refs": [ { "item_id": "MK-P07", "contribution_id": "C1" }, { "item_id": "MK-P07", "contribution_id": "C2" } ] }, { "card_id": "QE-RECOGNITION-DESIGN", "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P13", "contribution_refs": [ { "item_id": "HD-P13", "contribution_id": "C3" } ] }, { "card_id": "QE-RECOGNITION-DESIGN", "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I06", "contribution_refs": [ { "item_id": "MK-I06", "contribution_id": "C1" }, { "item_id": "MK-I06", "contribution_id": "C2" } ] }, { "card_id": "QE-RECOGNITION-DESIGN", "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-P03", "contribution_refs": [ { "item_id": "MK-P03", "contribution_id": "C2" } ] }, { "card_id": "QE-RECOGNITION-DESIGN", "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-P04", "contribution_refs": [ { "item_id": "MK-P04", "contribution_id": "C1" }, { "item_id": "MK-P04", "contribution_id": "C2" } ] } ], "evidence_reference_origins": [ { "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "container": "stack_roles", "owner_id": "D1", "assessment_id": "EV-HD-P07-C1" }, { "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "container": "stack_roles", "owner_id": "D1", "assessment_id": "EV-HD-P08-C1" }, { "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "container": "stack_roles", "owner_id": "D1", "assessment_id": "EV-HD-P08-C2" }, { "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "container": "stack_roles", "owner_id": "D1", "assessment_id": "EV-HD-P10-C1" }, { "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "container": "stack_roles", "owner_id": "D1", "assessment_id": "EV-HD-P10-C2" }, { "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "container": "stack_roles", "owner_id": "D1", "assessment_id": "EV-HD-P11-C1" }, { "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "container": "stack_roles", "owner_id": "D1", "assessment_id": "EV-HD-P11-C2" }, { "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "container": "stack_roles", "owner_id": "D1", "assessment_id": "EV-MK-I11-C1" }, { "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "container": "stack_roles", "owner_id": "D1", "assessment_id": "EV-MK-I11-C3" }, { "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "container": "stack_roles", "owner_id": "O1", "assessment_id": "EV-HD-P07-C2" }, { "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "container": "stack_roles", "owner_id": "O1", "assessment_id": "EV-HD-P09-C2" }, { "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "container": "case_observations", "owner_id": "OBS-MK-I03-C3", "assessment_id": "EV-CASE-MK-I03-C3" }, { "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "container": "stack_roles", "owner_id": "D1", "assessment_id": "EV-MK-I03-C1" }, { "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "container": "stack_roles", "owner_id": "D1", "assessment_id": "EV-MK-I07-C1" }, { "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "container": "stack_roles", "owner_id": "D1", "assessment_id": "EV-MK-I07-C2" }, { "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "container": "stack_roles", "owner_id": "D1", "assessment_id": "EV-MK-I09-C2" }, { "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "container": "stack_roles", "owner_id": "D1", "assessment_id": "EV-MK-I13-C1" }, { "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "container": "stack_roles", "owner_id": "D1", "assessment_id": "EV-MK-P20-C2" }, { "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "container": "stack_roles", "owner_id": "O1", "assessment_id": "EV-MK-I03-C2" }, { "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "container": "stack_roles", "owner_id": "O1", "assessment_id": "EV-MK-I09-C1" }, { "card_id": "QE-EX-TRUST", "container": "case_observations", "owner_id": "OBS-HD-P06-C3", "assessment_id": "EV-CASE-HD-P06-C3" }, { "card_id": "QE-EX-TRUST", "container": "stack_roles", "owner_id": "D1", "assessment_id": "EV-HD-P06-C2" }, { "card_id": "QE-EX-TRUST", "container": "stack_roles", "owner_id": "D1", "assessment_id": "EV-HD-P09-C1" }, { "card_id": "QE-EX-TRUST", "container": "stack_roles", "owner_id": "D1", "assessment_id": "EV-MK-I04-C1" }, { "card_id": "QE-EX-TRUST", "container": "stack_roles", "owner_id": "D1", "assessment_id": "EV-MK-I04-C2" }, { "card_id": "QE-EX-TRUST", "container": "stack_roles", "owner_id": "O1", "assessment_id": "EV-HD-P06-C1" }, { "card_id": "QE-FOLLOW-THROUGH", "container": "stack_roles", "owner_id": "D1", "assessment_id": "EV-MK-P07-C1" }, { "card_id": "QE-FOLLOW-THROUGH", "container": "stack_roles", "owner_id": "D1", "assessment_id": "EV-MK-P07-C2" }, { "card_id": "QE-RECOGNITION-DESIGN", "container": "stack_roles", "owner_id": "D1", "assessment_id": "EV-HD-P13-C3" }, { "card_id": "QE-RECOGNITION-DESIGN", "container": "stack_roles", "owner_id": "D1", "assessment_id": "EV-MK-I06-C1" }, { "card_id": "QE-RECOGNITION-DESIGN", "container": "stack_roles", "owner_id": "D1", "assessment_id": "EV-MK-P03-C2" }, { "card_id": "QE-RECOGNITION-DESIGN", "container": "stack_roles", "owner_id": "D1", "assessment_id": "EV-MK-P04-C2" }, { "card_id": "QE-RECOGNITION-DESIGN", "container": "stack_roles", "owner_id": "O1", "assessment_id": "EV-MK-I06-C2" }, { "card_id": "QE-RECOGNITION-DESIGN", "container": "stack_roles", "owner_id": "O1", "assessment_id": "EV-MK-P04-C1" } ], "supporting_source_ids": [ "SRC-HD-SUMMARY", "SRC-HD-TABLE", "SRC-MK-SUPPLIED", "SRC-MK-TABLE" ], "imported_provider": { "card_id": "QE-EX-TARGETS", "origin": "exact_migrated_fixture", "path": "examples/architecture/fixtures.json", "fixture_version": "0.5.0", "content_compared": true }, "limitations": "Identity and reference accounting only, not empirical evidence or semantic entailment." }, "review_version": "qe-canonical-review-0.1.2", "definition_version": "qe-canonical-batch-001-0.1.2", "review_status": "provisional_for_acceptance", "expected_results": { "APP-TRUST-READY": "conditionally_applicable", "APP-CUSTOMER-READY": "conditionally_applicable", "APP-FOLLOW-READY": "conditionally_applicable", "APP-RECOGNITION-READY": "conditionally_applicable", "APP-REWARDS-READY": "conditionally_applicable", "APP-SECOND-READY": "conditionally_applicable", "APP-PROVIDER-READY": "conditionally_applicable", "APP-TRUST-UNKNOWN": "undetermined", "APP-TRUST-OUTSIDE": "outside_recorded_conditions", "APP-CUSTOMER-UNKNOWN": "undetermined", "APP-CUSTOMER-OUTSIDE": "outside_recorded_conditions", "APP-FOLLOW-UNKNOWN": "undetermined", "APP-FOLLOW-OUTSIDE": "outside_recorded_conditions", "APP-RECOGNITION-UNKNOWN": "undetermined", "APP-RECOGNITION-OUTSIDE": "outside_recorded_conditions", "APP-REWARDS-UNKNOWN": "undetermined", "APP-REWARDS-OUTSIDE": "outside_recorded_conditions", "APP-SECOND-UNKNOWN": "undetermined", "APP-SECOND-OUTSIDE": "outside_recorded_conditions", "APP-PROVIDER-UNKNOWN": "undetermined" }, "application_results": [ { "application_id": "APP-TRUST-READY", "entry_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-TRUST", "role_id": "D1" }, "definition_scope_review": "reviewed", "case_applicability": "conditionally_applicable", "unknown_checks": [], "failed_checks": [], "evaluated_dimensions": [ "declared_scope", "required_role_objectives", "action_activation" ], "meaning": "Only explicitly declared obligations in the uses/requires closure are assessed. Missing checks are unknown. Not empirical validation, procedure completion, or action authorization." }, { "application_id": "APP-CUSTOMER-READY", "entry_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "role_id": "D1" }, "definition_scope_review": "reviewed", "case_applicability": "conditionally_applicable", "unknown_checks": [], "failed_checks": [], "evaluated_dimensions": [ "declared_scope", "required_role_objectives", "action_activation" ], "meaning": "Only explicitly declared obligations in the uses/requires closure are assessed. Missing checks are unknown. Not empirical validation, procedure completion, or action authorization." }, { "application_id": "APP-FOLLOW-READY", "entry_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-FOLLOW-THROUGH", "role_id": "D1" }, "definition_scope_review": "reviewed", "case_applicability": "conditionally_applicable", "unknown_checks": [], "failed_checks": [], "evaluated_dimensions": [ "declared_scope", "required_role_objectives", "action_activation" ], "meaning": "Only explicitly declared obligations in the uses/requires closure are assessed. Missing checks are unknown. Not empirical validation, procedure completion, or action authorization." }, { "application_id": "APP-RECOGNITION-READY", "entry_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-RECOGNITION-DESIGN", "role_id": "D1" }, "definition_scope_review": "reviewed", "case_applicability": "conditionally_applicable", "unknown_checks": [], "failed_checks": [], "evaluated_dimensions": [ "declared_scope", "required_role_objectives", "action_activation" ], "meaning": "Only explicitly declared obligations in the uses/requires closure are assessed. Missing checks are unknown. Not empirical validation, procedure completion, or action authorization." }, { "application_id": "APP-REWARDS-READY", "entry_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "role_id": "D1" }, "definition_scope_review": "reviewed", "case_applicability": "conditionally_applicable", "unknown_checks": [], "failed_checks": [], "evaluated_dimensions": [ "declared_scope", "required_role_objectives", "action_activation" ], "meaning": "Only explicitly declared obligations in the uses/requires closure are assessed. Missing checks are unknown. Not empirical validation, procedure completion, or action authorization." }, { "application_id": "APP-SECOND-READY", "entry_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-SECOND", "role_id": "D1" }, "definition_scope_review": "reviewed", "case_applicability": "conditionally_applicable", "unknown_checks": [], "failed_checks": [], "evaluated_dimensions": [ "declared_scope", "required_role_objectives", "action_activation" ], "meaning": "Only explicitly declared obligations in the uses/requires closure are assessed. Missing checks are unknown. Not empirical validation, procedure completion, or action authorization." }, { "application_id": "APP-PROVIDER-READY", "entry_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "role_id": "O1" }, "definition_scope_review": "reviewed", "case_applicability": "conditionally_applicable", "unknown_checks": [], "failed_checks": [], "evaluated_dimensions": [ "declared_scope", "required_role_objectives", "action_activation" ], "meaning": "Only explicitly declared obligations in the uses/requires closure are assessed. Missing checks are unknown. Not empirical validation, procedure completion, or action authorization." }, { "application_id": "APP-TRUST-UNKNOWN", "entry_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-TRUST", "role_id": "D1" }, "definition_scope_review": "reviewed", "case_applicability": "undetermined", "unknown_checks": [ { "owner_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-TRUST", "role_id": "D1" }, "condition_id": "D-AUTH" }, { "objective_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-TRUST", "role_id": "D1", "field": "objective" } } ], "failed_checks": [], "evaluated_dimensions": [ "declared_scope", "required_role_objectives", "action_activation" ], "meaning": "Only explicitly declared obligations in the uses/requires closure are assessed. Missing checks are unknown. Not empirical validation, procedure completion, or action authorization." }, { "application_id": "APP-TRUST-OUTSIDE", "entry_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-TRUST", "role_id": "D1" }, "definition_scope_review": "reviewed", "case_applicability": "outside_recorded_conditions", "unknown_checks": [], "failed_checks": [ { "objective_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-TRUST", "role_id": "D1", "field": "objective" } } ], "evaluated_dimensions": [ "declared_scope", "required_role_objectives", "action_activation" ], "meaning": "Only explicitly declared obligations in the uses/requires closure are assessed. Missing checks are unknown. Not empirical validation, procedure completion, or action authorization." }, { "application_id": "APP-CUSTOMER-UNKNOWN", "entry_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "role_id": "D1" }, "definition_scope_review": "reviewed", "case_applicability": "undetermined", "unknown_checks": [ { "owner_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "role_id": "D1" }, "condition_id": "D-INPUT" } ], "failed_checks": [], "evaluated_dimensions": [ "declared_scope", "required_role_objectives", "action_activation" ], "meaning": "Only explicitly declared obligations in the uses/requires closure are assessed. Missing checks are unknown. Not empirical validation, procedure completion, or action authorization." }, { "application_id": "APP-CUSTOMER-OUTSIDE", "entry_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "role_id": "D1" }, "definition_scope_review": "reviewed", "case_applicability": "outside_recorded_conditions", "unknown_checks": [], "failed_checks": [ { "owner_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "role_id": "D1" }, "condition_id": "D-AUTH" }, { "owner_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "role_id": "D1" }, "condition_id": "D-EXCLUDE" }, { "objective_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "role_id": "D1", "field": "objective" } } ], "evaluated_dimensions": [ "declared_scope", "required_role_objectives", "action_activation" ], "meaning": "Only explicitly declared obligations in the uses/requires closure are assessed. Missing checks are unknown. Not empirical validation, procedure completion, or action authorization." }, { "application_id": "APP-FOLLOW-UNKNOWN", "entry_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-FOLLOW-THROUGH", "role_id": "D1" }, "definition_scope_review": "reviewed", "case_applicability": "undetermined", "unknown_checks": [ { "owner_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-FOLLOW-THROUGH", "role_id": "D1" }, "condition_id": "D-CONTACT" } ], "failed_checks": [], "evaluated_dimensions": [ "declared_scope", "required_role_objectives", "action_activation" ], "meaning": "Only explicitly declared obligations in the uses/requires closure are assessed. Missing checks are unknown. Not empirical validation, procedure completion, or action authorization." }, { "application_id": "APP-FOLLOW-OUTSIDE", "entry_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-FOLLOW-THROUGH", "role_id": "D1" }, "definition_scope_review": "reviewed", "case_applicability": "outside_recorded_conditions", "unknown_checks": [], "failed_checks": [ { "trigger_ref": { "role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-FOLLOW-THROUGH", "role_id": "D1" }, "trigger_index": 0 } } ], "evaluated_dimensions": [ "declared_scope", "required_role_objectives", "action_activation" ], "meaning": "Only explicitly declared obligations in the uses/requires closure are assessed. Missing checks are unknown. Not empirical validation, procedure completion, or action authorization." }, { "application_id": "APP-RECOGNITION-UNKNOWN", "entry_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-RECOGNITION-DESIGN", "role_id": "D1" }, "definition_scope_review": "reviewed", "case_applicability": "undetermined", "unknown_checks": [ { "owner_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-RECOGNITION-DESIGN", "role_id": "D1" }, "condition_id": "D-BASIS" } ], "failed_checks": [], "evaluated_dimensions": [ "declared_scope", "required_role_objectives", "action_activation" ], "meaning": "Only explicitly declared obligations in the uses/requires closure are assessed. Missing checks are unknown. Not empirical validation, procedure completion, or action authorization." }, { "application_id": "APP-RECOGNITION-OUTSIDE", "entry_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-RECOGNITION-DESIGN", "role_id": "D1" }, "definition_scope_review": "reviewed", "case_applicability": "outside_recorded_conditions", "unknown_checks": [], "failed_checks": [ { "owner_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-RECOGNITION-DESIGN", "role_id": "D1" }, "condition_id": "D-EXCLUDE" }, { "objective_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-RECOGNITION-DESIGN", "role_id": "D1", "field": "objective" } } ], "evaluated_dimensions": [ "declared_scope", "required_role_objectives", "action_activation" ], "meaning": "Only explicitly declared obligations in the uses/requires closure are assessed. Missing checks are unknown. Not empirical validation, procedure completion, or action authorization." }, { "application_id": "APP-REWARDS-UNKNOWN", "entry_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "role_id": "D1" }, "definition_scope_review": "reviewed", "case_applicability": "undetermined", "unknown_checks": [ { "owner_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "role_id": "D1" }, "condition_id": "D-REVIEW" } ], "failed_checks": [], "evaluated_dimensions": [ "declared_scope", "required_role_objectives", "action_activation" ], "meaning": "Only explicitly declared obligations in the uses/requires closure are assessed. Missing checks are unknown. Not empirical validation, procedure completion, or action authorization." }, { "application_id": "APP-REWARDS-OUTSIDE", "entry_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "role_id": "D1" }, "definition_scope_review": "reviewed", "case_applicability": "outside_recorded_conditions", "unknown_checks": [], "failed_checks": [ { "objective_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "role_id": "D1", "field": "objective" } } ], "evaluated_dimensions": [ "declared_scope", "required_role_objectives", "action_activation" ], "meaning": "Only explicitly declared obligations in the uses/requires closure are assessed. Missing checks are unknown. Not empirical validation, procedure completion, or action authorization." }, { "application_id": "APP-SECOND-UNKNOWN", "entry_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-SECOND", "role_id": "D1" }, "definition_scope_review": "reviewed", "case_applicability": "undetermined", "unknown_checks": [ { "owner_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-SECOND", "role_id": "E1" }, "condition_id": "E-INPUT" } ], "failed_checks": [], "evaluated_dimensions": [ "declared_scope", "required_role_objectives", "action_activation" ], "meaning": "Only explicitly declared obligations in the uses/requires closure are assessed. Missing checks are unknown. Not empirical validation, procedure completion, or action authorization." }, { "application_id": "APP-SECOND-OUTSIDE", "entry_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-SECOND", "role_id": "D1" }, "definition_scope_review": "reviewed", "case_applicability": "outside_recorded_conditions", "unknown_checks": [], "failed_checks": [ { "objective_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-SECOND", "role_id": "D1", "field": "objective" } } ], "evaluated_dimensions": [ "declared_scope", "required_role_objectives", "action_activation" ], "meaning": "Only explicitly declared obligations in the uses/requires closure are assessed. Missing checks are unknown. Not empirical validation, procedure completion, or action authorization." }, { "application_id": "APP-PROVIDER-UNKNOWN", "entry_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "role_id": "O1" }, "definition_scope_review": "reviewed", "case_applicability": "undetermined", "unknown_checks": [ { "owner_ref": { "kind": "card", "card_id": "QE-EX-TARGETS" }, "condition_id": "S1" } ], "failed_checks": [], "evaluated_dimensions": [ "declared_scope", "required_role_objectives", "action_activation" ], "meaning": "Only explicitly declared obligations in the uses/requires closure are assessed. Missing checks are unknown. Not empirical validation, procedure completion, or action authorization." }, { "application_id": "APP-PILOT-QE48-C01-D1-READY", "entry_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE48-C01", "role_id": "D1" }, "definition_scope_review": "reviewed", "case_applicability": "conditionally_applicable", "unknown_checks": [], "failed_checks": [], "evaluated_dimensions": [ "declared_scope", "required_role_objectives", "action_activation" ], "meaning": "Only explicitly declared obligations in the uses/requires closure are assessed. Missing checks are unknown. Not empirical validation, procedure completion, or action authorization." }, { "application_id": "APP-PILOT-QE48-C01-D1-UNKNOWN", "entry_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE48-C01", "role_id": "D1" }, "definition_scope_review": "reviewed", "case_applicability": "undetermined", "unknown_checks": [ { "owner_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE48-C01", "role_id": "D1" }, "condition_id": "D-VALUES" } ], "failed_checks": [], "evaluated_dimensions": [ "declared_scope", "required_role_objectives", "action_activation" ], "meaning": "Only explicitly declared obligations in the uses/requires closure are assessed. Missing checks are unknown. Not empirical validation, procedure completion, or action authorization." }, { "application_id": "APP-PILOT-QE48-C01-D1-OUTSIDE", "entry_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE48-C01", "role_id": "D1" }, "definition_scope_review": "reviewed", "case_applicability": "outside_recorded_conditions", "unknown_checks": [], "failed_checks": [ { "owner_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE48-C01", "role_id": "D1" }, "condition_id": "D-AUTH" } ], "evaluated_dimensions": [ "declared_scope", "required_role_objectives", "action_activation" ], "meaning": "Only explicitly declared obligations in the uses/requires closure are assessed. Missing checks are unknown. Not empirical validation, procedure completion, or action authorization." }, { "application_id": "APP-PILOT-QE48-C01-D2-READY", "entry_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE48-C01", "role_id": "D2" }, "definition_scope_review": "reviewed", "case_applicability": "conditionally_applicable", "unknown_checks": [], "failed_checks": [], "evaluated_dimensions": [ "declared_scope", "required_role_objectives", "action_activation" ], "meaning": "Only explicitly declared obligations in the uses/requires closure are assessed. Missing checks are unknown. Not empirical validation, procedure completion, or action authorization." }, { "application_id": "APP-PILOT-QE48-C01-D2-UNKNOWN", "entry_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE48-C01", "role_id": "D2" }, "definition_scope_review": "reviewed", "case_applicability": "undetermined", "unknown_checks": [ { "owner_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE48-C01", "role_id": "D2" }, "condition_id": "D2-INPUT" } ], "failed_checks": [], "evaluated_dimensions": [ "declared_scope", "required_role_objectives", "action_activation" ], "meaning": "Only explicitly declared obligations in the uses/requires closure are assessed. Missing checks are unknown. Not empirical validation, procedure completion, or action authorization." }, { "application_id": "APP-PILOT-QE48-C01-D2-OUTSIDE", "entry_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE48-C01", "role_id": "D2" }, "definition_scope_review": "reviewed", "case_applicability": "outside_recorded_conditions", "unknown_checks": [], "failed_checks": [ { "owner_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE48-C01", "role_id": "D2" }, "condition_id": "D2-RESOURCE" } ], "evaluated_dimensions": [ "declared_scope", "required_role_objectives", "action_activation" ], "meaning": "Only explicitly declared obligations in the uses/requires closure are assessed. Missing checks are unknown. Not empirical validation, procedure completion, or action authorization." }, { "application_id": "APP-PILOT-QE48-C03-E1-READY", "entry_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE48-C03", "role_id": "E1" }, "definition_scope_review": "reviewed", "case_applicability": "conditionally_applicable", "unknown_checks": [], "failed_checks": [], "evaluated_dimensions": [ "declared_scope", "required_role_objectives", "action_activation" ], "meaning": "Only explicitly declared obligations in the uses/requires closure are assessed. Missing checks are unknown. Not empirical validation, procedure completion, or action authorization." }, { "application_id": "APP-PILOT-QE48-C03-E1-UNKNOWN", "entry_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE48-C03", "role_id": "E1" }, "definition_scope_review": "reviewed", "case_applicability": "undetermined", "unknown_checks": [ { "owner_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE48-C03", "role_id": "E1" }, "condition_id": "E-DATA" } ], "failed_checks": [], "evaluated_dimensions": [ "declared_scope", "required_role_objectives", "action_activation" ], "meaning": "Only explicitly declared obligations in the uses/requires closure are assessed. Missing checks are unknown. Not empirical validation, procedure completion, or action authorization." }, { "application_id": "APP-PILOT-QE48-C03-E1-OUTSIDE", "entry_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE48-C03", "role_id": "E1" }, "definition_scope_review": "reviewed", "case_applicability": "outside_recorded_conditions", "unknown_checks": [], "failed_checks": [ { "owner_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE48-C03", "role_id": "E1" }, "condition_id": "E-MODEL" } ], "evaluated_dimensions": [ "declared_scope", "required_role_objectives", "action_activation" ], "meaning": "Only explicitly declared obligations in the uses/requires closure are assessed. Missing checks are unknown. Not empirical validation, procedure completion, or action authorization." }, { "application_id": "APP-PILOT-QE48-C30-E1-READY", "entry_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE48-C30", "role_id": "E1" }, "definition_scope_review": "reviewed", "case_applicability": "conditionally_applicable", "unknown_checks": [], "failed_checks": [], "evaluated_dimensions": [ "declared_scope", "required_role_objectives", "action_activation" ], "meaning": "Only explicitly declared obligations in the uses/requires closure are assessed. Missing checks are unknown. Not empirical validation, procedure completion, or action authorization." }, { "application_id": "APP-PILOT-QE48-C30-E1-UNKNOWN", "entry_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE48-C30", "role_id": "E1" }, "definition_scope_review": "reviewed", "case_applicability": "undetermined", "unknown_checks": [ { "owner_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE48-C30", "role_id": "E1" }, "condition_id": "E-PURPOSE" } ], "failed_checks": [], "evaluated_dimensions": [ "declared_scope", "required_role_objectives", "action_activation" ], "meaning": "Only explicitly declared obligations in the uses/requires closure are assessed. Missing checks are unknown. Not empirical validation, procedure completion, or action authorization." }, { "application_id": "APP-PILOT-QE48-C30-E1-OUTSIDE", "entry_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE48-C30", "role_id": "E1" }, "definition_scope_review": "reviewed", "case_applicability": "outside_recorded_conditions", "unknown_checks": [], "failed_checks": [ { "owner_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE48-C30", "role_id": "E1" }, "condition_id": "E-PURPOSE" } ], "evaluated_dimensions": [ "declared_scope", "required_role_objectives", "action_activation" ], "meaning": "Only explicitly declared obligations in the uses/requires closure are assessed. Missing checks are unknown. Not empirical validation, procedure completion, or action authorization." }, { "application_id": "APP-PILOT-QE48-C01-D1-FORCED-CHOICE", "entry_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE48-C01", "role_id": "D1" }, "definition_scope_review": "reviewed", "case_applicability": "conditionally_applicable", "unknown_checks": [], "failed_checks": [], "evaluated_dimensions": [ "declared_scope", "required_role_objectives", "action_activation" ], "meaning": "Only explicitly declared obligations in the uses/requires closure are assessed. Missing checks are unknown. Not empirical validation, procedure completion, or action authorization." }, { "application_id": "APP-PILOT-QE48-C01-D2-KNOWN-THRESHOLD", "entry_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE48-C01", "role_id": "D2" }, "definition_scope_review": "reviewed", "case_applicability": "outside_recorded_conditions", "unknown_checks": [], "failed_checks": [ { "owner_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE48-C01", "role_id": "D2" }, "condition_id": "D2-INTERACTION" } ], "evaluated_dimensions": [ "declared_scope", "required_role_objectives", "action_activation" ], "meaning": "Only explicitly declared obligations in the uses/requires closure are assessed. Missing checks are unknown. Not empirical validation, procedure completion, or action authorization." }, { "application_id": "APP-PILOT-QE48-C01-D2-KNOWN-COMPLEMENTARITY", "entry_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE48-C01", "role_id": "D2" }, "definition_scope_review": "reviewed", "case_applicability": "outside_recorded_conditions", "unknown_checks": [], "failed_checks": [ { "owner_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE48-C01", "role_id": "D2" }, "condition_id": "D2-INTERACTION" } ], "evaluated_dimensions": [ "declared_scope", "required_role_objectives", "action_activation" ], "meaning": "Only explicitly declared obligations in the uses/requires closure are assessed. Missing checks are unknown. Not empirical validation, procedure completion, or action authorization." }, { "application_id": "APP-PILOT-QE48-C03-E1-INVENTORY-UNKNOWN", "entry_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE48-C03", "role_id": "E1" }, "definition_scope_review": "reviewed", "case_applicability": "undetermined", "unknown_checks": [ { "owner_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE48-C03", "role_id": "E1" }, "condition_id": "E-ACCOUNTING" } ], "failed_checks": [], "evaluated_dimensions": [ "declared_scope", "required_role_objectives", "action_activation" ], "meaning": "Only explicitly declared obligations in the uses/requires closure are assessed. Missing checks are unknown. Not empirical validation, procedure completion, or action authorization." }, { "application_id": "APP-PILOT-QE48-C03-E1-YIELD-OUTSIDE", "entry_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE48-C03", "role_id": "E1" }, "definition_scope_review": "reviewed", "case_applicability": "outside_recorded_conditions", "unknown_checks": [], "failed_checks": [ { "owner_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE48-C03", "role_id": "E1" }, "condition_id": "E-ACCOUNTING" } ], "evaluated_dimensions": [ "declared_scope", "required_role_objectives", "action_activation" ], "meaning": "Only explicitly declared obligations in the uses/requires closure are assessed. Missing checks are unknown. Not empirical validation, procedure completion, or action authorization." } ], "application_links": [ { "application_id": "APP-TRUST-READY", "entry_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-TRUST", "role_id": "D1" }, "source_paths": [ { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I04", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I04", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-I04", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I04-C1", "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-I04-C1", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-TRUST", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-I04-C1" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I04", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I04", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-I04", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I04-C2", "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-I04-C2", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-TRUST", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-I04-C2" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "HD-P06", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P06", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-HD-P06", "expression_ref": "X-HD-P06-C1", "mapping_ref": "MAP-HD-P06-C1", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-TRUST", "role_id": "O1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-HD-P06-C1" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "HD-P06", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P06", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-HD-P06", "expression_ref": "X-HD-P06-C2", "mapping_ref": "MAP-HD-P06-C2", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-TRUST", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-HD-P06-C2" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "HD-P06", "contribution_id": "C3" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P06", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-HD-P06", "expression_ref": "X-HD-P06-C3", "mapping_ref": null, "observation_ref": { "kind": "observation", "card_id": "QE-EX-TRUST", "observation_id": "OBS-HD-P06-C3" }, "assembly_role_ref": null, "assessment_ref": "EV-CASE-HD-P06-C3" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "HD-P09", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P09", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-HD-P09", "expression_ref": "X-HD-P09-C1", "mapping_ref": "MAP-HD-P09-C1", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-TRUST", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-HD-P09-C1" } ], "lineage_note": "Source paths are navigation to this card, not evidence for this hypothetical case or proof of its procedure.", "required_members": [ { "kind": "relation", "card_id": "QE-EX-TRUST", "relation_id": "R3" }, { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-TRUST", "role_id": "D1" }, { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-TRUST", "role_id": "E1" } ], "required_conditions": [ { "reference": { "owner_ref": { "kind": "card", "card_id": "QE-EX-TRUST" }, "condition_id": "S1" }, "condition": { "condition_id": "S1", "kind": "applicability", "statement": "Parties consider a cooperative business relationship and can assess relevant conduct." } }, { "reference": { "owner_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-TRUST", "role_id": "D1" }, "condition_id": "D-AUTH" }, "condition": { "condition_id": "D-AUTH", "kind": "applicability", "statement": "The actor may review the relationship and communicate through an authorized, confidentiality-preserving channel." } }, { "reference": { "owner_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-TRUST", "role_id": "D1" }, "condition_id": "D-OPTION" }, "condition": { "condition_id": "D-OPTION", "kind": "applicability", "statement": "At least one proposed arrangement, including pausing or declining cooperation, can be compared against both parties' constraints." } } ], "required_objectives": [ { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-TRUST", "role_id": "D1", "field": "objective" } ], "required_activations": [ { "reference": { "role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-TRUST", "role_id": "D1" }, "trigger_index": 0 }, "statement": "A cooperative business arrangement is being proposed, renewed or materially reconsidered." } ] }, { "application_id": "APP-CUSTOMER-READY", "entry_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "role_id": "D1" }, "source_paths": [ { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I11", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I11", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-I11", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I11-C1", "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-I11-C1", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-I11-C1" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I11", "contribution_id": "C3" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I11", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-I11", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I11-C3", "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-I11-C3", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-I11-C3" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "HD-P07", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P07", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-HD-P07", "expression_ref": "X-HD-P07-C1", "mapping_ref": "MAP-HD-P07-C1", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-HD-P07-C1" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "HD-P07", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P07", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-HD-P07", "expression_ref": "X-HD-P07-C2", "mapping_ref": "MAP-HD-P07-C2", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "role_id": "O1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-HD-P07-C2" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "HD-P08", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P08", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-HD-P08", "expression_ref": "X-HD-P08-C1", "mapping_ref": "MAP-HD-P08-C1", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-HD-P08-C1" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "HD-P08", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P08", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-HD-P08", "expression_ref": "X-HD-P08-C2", "mapping_ref": "MAP-HD-P08-C2", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-HD-P08-C2" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "HD-P09", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P09", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-HD-P09", "expression_ref": "X-HD-P09-C2", "mapping_ref": "MAP-HD-P09-C2", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "role_id": "O1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-HD-P09-C2" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "HD-P10", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P10", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-HD-P10", "expression_ref": "X-HD-P10-C1", "mapping_ref": "MAP-HD-P10-C1", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-HD-P10-C1" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "HD-P10", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P10", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-HD-P10", "expression_ref": "X-HD-P10-C2", "mapping_ref": "MAP-HD-P10-C2", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-HD-P10-C2" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "HD-P11", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P11", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-HD-P11", "expression_ref": "X-HD-P11-C1", "mapping_ref": "MAP-HD-P11-C1", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-HD-P11-C1" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "HD-P11", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P11", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-HD-P11", "expression_ref": "X-HD-P11-C2", "mapping_ref": "MAP-HD-P11-C2", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-HD-P11-C2" } ], "lineage_note": "Source paths are navigation to this card, not evidence for this hypothetical case or proof of its procedure.", "required_members": [ { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "role_id": "D1" } ], "required_conditions": [ { "reference": { "owner_ref": { "kind": "card", "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE" }, "condition_id": "S1" }, "condition": { "condition_id": "S1", "kind": "applicability", "statement": "An identified customer group and task are connected to a business offering or operating choice." } }, { "reference": { "owner_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "role_id": "D1" }, "condition_id": "D-AUTH" }, "condition": { "condition_id": "D-AUTH", "kind": "applicability", "statement": "The decision-maker can assess relevant safety, obligations and commercial constraints and has authority for the proposed choice." } }, { "reference": { "owner_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "role_id": "D1" }, "condition_id": "D-EXCLUDE" }, "condition": { "condition_id": "D-EXCLUDE", "kind": "boundary", "statement": "The comparison requires ignoring a mandatory safeguard or treating an unavailable essential input as verified." } }, { "reference": { "owner_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "role_id": "D1" }, "condition_id": "D-INPUT" }, "condition": { "condition_id": "D-INPUT", "kind": "applicability", "statement": "At least two feasible alternatives, including a permitted status quo or no change, and a way to examine customer-task results can be specified." } } ], "required_objectives": [ { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "role_id": "D1", "field": "objective" } ], "required_activations": [ { "reference": { "role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "role_id": "D1" }, "trigger_index": 0 }, "statement": "A choice between offerings or operating alternatives could materially change the specified customer task." } ] }, { "application_id": "APP-FOLLOW-READY", "entry_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-FOLLOW-THROUGH", "role_id": "D1" }, "source_paths": [ { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-P07", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-P07", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-P07", "expression_ref": "X-MK-P07-C1", "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-P07-C1", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-FOLLOW-THROUGH", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-P07-C1" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-P07", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-P07", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-P07", "expression_ref": "X-MK-P07-C2", "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-P07-C2", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-FOLLOW-THROUGH", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-P07-C2" } ], "lineage_note": "Source paths are navigation to this card, not evidence for this hypothetical case or proof of its procedure.", "required_members": [ { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-FOLLOW-THROUGH", "role_id": "D1" } ], "required_conditions": [ { "reference": { "owner_ref": { "kind": "card", "card_id": "QE-FOLLOW-THROUGH" }, "condition_id": "S1" }, "condition": { "condition_id": "S1", "kind": "applicability", "statement": "An identifiable commitment has been acknowledged by a responsible actor, with a completion condition that is agreed or can be clarified." } }, { "reference": { "owner_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-FOLLOW-THROUGH", "role_id": "D1" }, "condition_id": "D-CONTACT" }, "condition": { "condition_id": "D-CONTACT", "kind": "applicability", "statement": "A legitimate channel exists to clarify the obligation with the affected party or escalate it to a responsible authority." } }, { "reference": { "owner_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-FOLLOW-THROUGH", "role_id": "D1" }, "condition_id": "D-EXCLUDE" }, "condition": { "condition_id": "D-EXCLUDE", "kind": "boundary", "statement": "The procedure would require performing an unsafe or prohibited act merely to honor the original promise." } } ], "required_objectives": [ { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-FOLLOW-THROUGH", "role_id": "D1", "field": "objective" } ], "required_activations": [ { "reference": { "role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-FOLLOW-THROUGH", "role_id": "D1" }, "trigger_index": 0 }, "statement": "An acknowledged commitment is due for action or its completion is threatened." } ] }, { "application_id": "APP-RECOGNITION-READY", "entry_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-RECOGNITION-DESIGN", "role_id": "D1" }, "source_paths": [ { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-P03", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-P03", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-P03", "expression_ref": "X-MK-P03-C2", "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-P03-C2", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-RECOGNITION-DESIGN", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-P03-C2" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-P04", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-P04", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-P04", "expression_ref": "X-MK-P04-C1", "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-P04-C1", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-RECOGNITION-DESIGN", "role_id": "O1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-P04-C1" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-P04", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-P04", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-P04", "expression_ref": "X-MK-P04-C2", "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-P04-C2", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-RECOGNITION-DESIGN", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-P04-C2" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I06", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I06", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-I06", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I06-C1", "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-I06-C1", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-RECOGNITION-DESIGN", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-I06-C1" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I06", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I06", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-I06", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I06-C2", "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-I06-C2", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-RECOGNITION-DESIGN", "role_id": "O1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-I06-C2" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "HD-P13", "contribution_id": "C3" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P13", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-HD-P13", "expression_ref": "X-HD-P13-C3", "mapping_ref": "MAP-HD-P13-C3", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-RECOGNITION-DESIGN", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-HD-P13-C3" } ], "lineage_note": "Source paths are navigation to this card, not evidence for this hypothetical case or proof of its procedure.", "required_members": [ { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-RECOGNITION-DESIGN", "role_id": "D1" } ], "required_conditions": [ { "reference": { "owner_ref": { "kind": "card", "card_id": "QE-RECOGNITION-DESIGN" }, "condition_id": "S1" }, "condition": { "condition_id": "S1", "kind": "applicability", "statement": "An organizational contribution, recipient and context for acknowledgment can be identified." } }, { "reference": { "owner_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-RECOGNITION-DESIGN", "role_id": "D1" }, "condition_id": "D-AUTH" }, "condition": { "condition_id": "D-AUTH", "kind": "applicability", "statement": "The actor can choose acknowledgment within available resources, privacy requirements and any compensation or award obligations." } }, { "reference": { "owner_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-RECOGNITION-DESIGN", "role_id": "D1" }, "condition_id": "D-BASIS" }, "condition": { "condition_id": "D-BASIS", "kind": "applicability", "statement": "A credible basis for attributing the contribution and a permitted way to assess recipient and context fit are available." } }, { "reference": { "owner_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-RECOGNITION-DESIGN", "role_id": "D1" }, "condition_id": "D-EXCLUDE" }, "condition": { "condition_id": "D-EXCLUDE", "kind": "boundary", "statement": "Recognition would disclose protected information, humiliate a recipient or replace an owed payment or required corrective action." } } ], "required_objectives": [ { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-RECOGNITION-DESIGN", "role_id": "D1", "field": "objective" } ], "required_activations": [ { "reference": { "role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-RECOGNITION-DESIGN", "role_id": "D1" }, "trigger_index": 0 }, "statement": "There is an occasion to acknowledge an identifiable organizational contribution." } ] }, { "application_id": "APP-REWARDS-READY", "entry_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "role_id": "D1" }, "source_paths": [ { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-P20", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-P20", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-P20", "expression_ref": "X-MK-P20-C2", "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-P20-C2", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-P20-C2" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I03", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I03", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-I03", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I03-C1", "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-I03-C1", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-I03-C1" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I03", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I03", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-I03", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I03-C2", "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-I03-C2", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "role_id": "O1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-I03-C2" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I03", "contribution_id": "C3" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I03", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-I03", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I03-C3", "mapping_ref": null, "observation_ref": { "kind": "observation", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "observation_id": "OBS-MK-I03-C3" }, "assembly_role_ref": null, "assessment_ref": "EV-CASE-MK-I03-C3" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I07", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I07", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-I07", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I07-C1", "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-I07-C1", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-I07-C1" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I07", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I07", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-I07", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I07-C2", "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-I07-C2", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-I07-C2" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I09", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I09", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-I09", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I09-C1", "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-I09-C1", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "role_id": "O1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-I09-C1" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I09", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I09", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-I09", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I09-C2", "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-I09-C2", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-I09-C2" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I13", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I13", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-I13", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I13-C1", "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-I13-C1", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-I13-C1" } ], "lineage_note": "Source paths are navigation to this card, not evidence for this hypothetical case or proof of its procedure.", "required_members": [ { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "role_id": "D1" } ], "required_conditions": [ { "reference": { "owner_ref": { "kind": "card", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES" }, "condition_id": "S1" }, "condition": { "condition_id": "S1", "kind": "applicability", "statement": "An organization can change consequential rewards and observe relevant behavior." } }, { "reference": { "owner_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "role_id": "D1" }, "condition_id": "D-REVIEW" }, "condition": { "condition_id": "D-REVIEW", "kind": "applicability", "statement": "The actor has authority to review the reward rule and a feasible way to examine desired outcomes and harmful shortcuts beyond the rewarded count alone." } }, { "reference": { "owner_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "role_id": "D1" }, "condition_id": "D-RULE" }, "condition": { "condition_id": "D-RULE", "kind": "applicability", "statement": "The proposed reward, its eligibility rule and the intended contribution can be stated separately." } } ], "required_objectives": [ { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "role_id": "D1", "field": "objective" } ], "required_activations": [ { "reference": { "role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "role_id": "D1" }, "trigger_index": 0 }, "statement": "A consequential reward rule is being designed or reviewed." } ] }, { "application_id": "APP-SECOND-READY", "entry_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-SECOND", "role_id": "D1" }, "source_paths": [], "lineage_note": "No supplied-table route. The concept derives from the pinned architecture fixture; the current method includes the explicitly versioned V01 refinement.", "required_members": [ { "kind": "relation", "card_id": "QE-EX-SECOND", "relation_id": "R3" }, { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-SECOND", "role_id": "D1" }, { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-SECOND", "role_id": "E1" } ], "required_conditions": [ { "reference": { "owner_ref": { "kind": "card", "card_id": "QE-EX-SECOND" }, "condition_id": "S1" }, "condition": { "condition_id": "S1", "kind": "applicability", "statement": "Dependencies or adaptive responses could materially change the outcome of an action." } }, { "reference": { "owner_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-SECOND", "role_id": "D1" }, "condition_id": "D-OPTIONS" }, "condition": { "condition_id": "D-OPTIONS", "kind": "applicability", "statement": "Feasible options, the affected parties' objective and a decision deadline can be stated for comparison." } }, { "reference": { "owner_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-SECOND", "role_id": "E1" }, "condition_id": "E-INPUT" }, "condition": { "condition_id": "E-INPUT", "kind": "applicability", "statement": "A candidate action, an initial outcome hypothesis and a decision time budget can be specified; uncertain links can be kept explicit." } } ], "required_objectives": [ { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-SECOND", "role_id": "D1", "field": "objective" } ], "required_activations": [ { "reference": { "role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-SECOND", "role_id": "D1" }, "trigger_index": 0 }, "statement": "Before a consequential decision with material dependencies." } ] }, { "application_id": "APP-PROVIDER-READY", "entry_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "role_id": "O1" }, "source_paths": [ { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-P20", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-P20", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-P20", "expression_ref": "X-MK-P20-C2", "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-P20-C2", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-P20-C2" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I03", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I03", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-I03", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I03-C1", "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-I03-C1", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-I03-C1" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I03", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I03", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-I03", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I03-C2", "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-I03-C2", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "role_id": "O1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-I03-C2" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I03", "contribution_id": "C3" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I03", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-I03", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I03-C3", "mapping_ref": null, "observation_ref": { "kind": "observation", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "observation_id": "OBS-MK-I03-C3" }, "assembly_role_ref": null, "assessment_ref": "EV-CASE-MK-I03-C3" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I07", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I07", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-I07", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I07-C1", "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-I07-C1", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-I07-C1" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I07", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I07", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-I07", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I07-C2", "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-I07-C2", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-I07-C2" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I09", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I09", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-I09", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I09-C1", "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-I09-C1", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "role_id": "O1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-I09-C1" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I09", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I09", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-I09", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I09-C2", "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-I09-C2", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-I09-C2" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I13", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I13", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-I13", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I13-C1", "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-I13-C1", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-I13-C1" } ], "lineage_note": "Source paths are navigation to this card, not evidence for this hypothetical case or proof of its procedure.", "required_members": [ { "kind": "relation", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "relation_id": "U1" }, { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "role_id": "O1" }, { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-TARGETS", "role_id": "O1" } ], "required_conditions": [ { "reference": { "owner_ref": { "kind": "card", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES" }, "condition_id": "S1" }, "condition": { "condition_id": "S1", "kind": "applicability", "statement": "An organization can change consequential rewards and observe relevant behavior." } }, { "reference": { "owner_ref": { "kind": "card", "card_id": "QE-EX-TARGETS" }, "condition_id": "S1" }, "condition": { "condition_id": "S1", "kind": "applicability", "statement": "Adaptive actors can influence a measure tied to consequences they care about." } } ], "required_objectives": [], "required_activations": [] }, { "application_id": "APP-TRUST-UNKNOWN", "entry_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-TRUST", "role_id": "D1" }, "source_paths": [ { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I04", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I04", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-I04", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I04-C1", "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-I04-C1", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-TRUST", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-I04-C1" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I04", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I04", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-I04", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I04-C2", "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-I04-C2", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-TRUST", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-I04-C2" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "HD-P06", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P06", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-HD-P06", "expression_ref": "X-HD-P06-C1", "mapping_ref": "MAP-HD-P06-C1", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-TRUST", "role_id": "O1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-HD-P06-C1" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "HD-P06", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P06", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-HD-P06", "expression_ref": "X-HD-P06-C2", "mapping_ref": "MAP-HD-P06-C2", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-TRUST", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-HD-P06-C2" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "HD-P06", "contribution_id": "C3" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P06", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-HD-P06", "expression_ref": "X-HD-P06-C3", "mapping_ref": null, "observation_ref": { "kind": "observation", "card_id": "QE-EX-TRUST", "observation_id": "OBS-HD-P06-C3" }, "assembly_role_ref": null, "assessment_ref": "EV-CASE-HD-P06-C3" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "HD-P09", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P09", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-HD-P09", "expression_ref": "X-HD-P09-C1", "mapping_ref": "MAP-HD-P09-C1", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-TRUST", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-HD-P09-C1" } ], "lineage_note": "Source paths are navigation to this card, not evidence for this hypothetical case or proof of its procedure.", "required_members": [ { "kind": "relation", "card_id": "QE-EX-TRUST", "relation_id": "R3" }, { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-TRUST", "role_id": "D1" }, { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-TRUST", "role_id": "E1" } ], "required_conditions": [ { "reference": { "owner_ref": { "kind": "card", "card_id": "QE-EX-TRUST" }, "condition_id": "S1" }, "condition": { "condition_id": "S1", "kind": "applicability", "statement": "Parties consider a cooperative business relationship and can assess relevant conduct." } }, { "reference": { "owner_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-TRUST", "role_id": "D1" }, "condition_id": "D-AUTH" }, "condition": { "condition_id": "D-AUTH", "kind": "applicability", "statement": "The actor may review the relationship and communicate through an authorized, confidentiality-preserving channel." } }, { "reference": { "owner_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-TRUST", "role_id": "D1" }, "condition_id": "D-OPTION" }, "condition": { "condition_id": "D-OPTION", "kind": "applicability", "statement": "At least one proposed arrangement, including pausing or declining cooperation, can be compared against both parties' constraints." } } ], "required_objectives": [ { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-TRUST", "role_id": "D1", "field": "objective" } ], "required_activations": [ { "reference": { "role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-TRUST", "role_id": "D1" }, "trigger_index": 0 }, "statement": "A cooperative business arrangement is being proposed, renewed or materially reconsidered." } ] }, { "application_id": "APP-TRUST-OUTSIDE", "entry_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-TRUST", "role_id": "D1" }, "source_paths": [ { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I04", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I04", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-I04", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I04-C1", "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-I04-C1", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-TRUST", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-I04-C1" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I04", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I04", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-I04", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I04-C2", "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-I04-C2", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-TRUST", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-I04-C2" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "HD-P06", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P06", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-HD-P06", "expression_ref": "X-HD-P06-C1", "mapping_ref": "MAP-HD-P06-C1", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-TRUST", "role_id": "O1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-HD-P06-C1" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "HD-P06", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P06", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-HD-P06", "expression_ref": "X-HD-P06-C2", "mapping_ref": "MAP-HD-P06-C2", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-TRUST", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-HD-P06-C2" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "HD-P06", "contribution_id": "C3" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P06", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-HD-P06", "expression_ref": "X-HD-P06-C3", "mapping_ref": null, "observation_ref": { "kind": "observation", "card_id": "QE-EX-TRUST", "observation_id": "OBS-HD-P06-C3" }, "assembly_role_ref": null, "assessment_ref": "EV-CASE-HD-P06-C3" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "HD-P09", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P09", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-HD-P09", "expression_ref": "X-HD-P09-C1", "mapping_ref": "MAP-HD-P09-C1", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-TRUST", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-HD-P09-C1" } ], "lineage_note": "Source paths are navigation to this card, not evidence for this hypothetical case or proof of its procedure.", "required_members": [ { "kind": "relation", "card_id": "QE-EX-TRUST", "relation_id": "R3" }, { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-TRUST", "role_id": "D1" }, { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-TRUST", "role_id": "E1" } ], "required_conditions": [ { "reference": { "owner_ref": { "kind": "card", "card_id": "QE-EX-TRUST" }, "condition_id": "S1" }, "condition": { "condition_id": "S1", "kind": "applicability", "statement": "Parties consider a cooperative business relationship and can assess relevant conduct." } }, { "reference": { "owner_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-TRUST", "role_id": "D1" }, "condition_id": "D-AUTH" }, "condition": { "condition_id": "D-AUTH", "kind": "applicability", "statement": "The actor may review the relationship and communicate through an authorized, confidentiality-preserving channel." } }, { "reference": { "owner_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-TRUST", "role_id": "D1" }, "condition_id": "D-OPTION" }, "condition": { "condition_id": "D-OPTION", "kind": "applicability", "statement": "At least one proposed arrangement, including pausing or declining cooperation, can be compared against both parties' constraints." } } ], "required_objectives": [ { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-TRUST", "role_id": "D1", "field": "objective" } ], "required_activations": [ { "reference": { "role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-TRUST", "role_id": "D1" }, "trigger_index": 0 }, "statement": "A cooperative business arrangement is being proposed, renewed or materially reconsidered." } ] }, { "application_id": "APP-CUSTOMER-UNKNOWN", "entry_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "role_id": "D1" }, "source_paths": [ { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I11", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I11", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-I11", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I11-C1", "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-I11-C1", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-I11-C1" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I11", "contribution_id": "C3" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I11", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-I11", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I11-C3", "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-I11-C3", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-I11-C3" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "HD-P07", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P07", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-HD-P07", "expression_ref": "X-HD-P07-C1", "mapping_ref": "MAP-HD-P07-C1", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-HD-P07-C1" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "HD-P07", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P07", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-HD-P07", "expression_ref": "X-HD-P07-C2", "mapping_ref": "MAP-HD-P07-C2", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "role_id": "O1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-HD-P07-C2" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "HD-P08", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P08", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-HD-P08", "expression_ref": "X-HD-P08-C1", "mapping_ref": "MAP-HD-P08-C1", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-HD-P08-C1" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "HD-P08", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P08", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-HD-P08", "expression_ref": "X-HD-P08-C2", "mapping_ref": "MAP-HD-P08-C2", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-HD-P08-C2" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "HD-P09", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P09", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-HD-P09", "expression_ref": "X-HD-P09-C2", "mapping_ref": "MAP-HD-P09-C2", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "role_id": "O1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-HD-P09-C2" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "HD-P10", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P10", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-HD-P10", "expression_ref": "X-HD-P10-C1", "mapping_ref": "MAP-HD-P10-C1", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-HD-P10-C1" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "HD-P10", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P10", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-HD-P10", "expression_ref": "X-HD-P10-C2", "mapping_ref": "MAP-HD-P10-C2", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-HD-P10-C2" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "HD-P11", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P11", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-HD-P11", "expression_ref": "X-HD-P11-C1", "mapping_ref": "MAP-HD-P11-C1", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-HD-P11-C1" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "HD-P11", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P11", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-HD-P11", "expression_ref": "X-HD-P11-C2", "mapping_ref": "MAP-HD-P11-C2", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-HD-P11-C2" } ], "lineage_note": "Source paths are navigation to this card, not evidence for this hypothetical case or proof of its procedure.", "required_members": [ { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "role_id": "D1" } ], "required_conditions": [ { "reference": { "owner_ref": { "kind": "card", "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE" }, "condition_id": "S1" }, "condition": { "condition_id": "S1", "kind": "applicability", "statement": "An identified customer group and task are connected to a business offering or operating choice." } }, { "reference": { "owner_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "role_id": "D1" }, "condition_id": "D-AUTH" }, "condition": { "condition_id": "D-AUTH", "kind": "applicability", "statement": "The decision-maker can assess relevant safety, obligations and commercial constraints and has authority for the proposed choice." } }, { "reference": { "owner_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "role_id": "D1" }, "condition_id": "D-EXCLUDE" }, "condition": { "condition_id": "D-EXCLUDE", "kind": "boundary", "statement": "The comparison requires ignoring a mandatory safeguard or treating an unavailable essential input as verified." } }, { "reference": { "owner_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "role_id": "D1" }, "condition_id": "D-INPUT" }, "condition": { "condition_id": "D-INPUT", "kind": "applicability", "statement": "At least two feasible alternatives, including a permitted status quo or no change, and a way to examine customer-task results can be specified." } } ], "required_objectives": [ { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "role_id": "D1", "field": "objective" } ], "required_activations": [ { "reference": { "role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "role_id": "D1" }, "trigger_index": 0 }, "statement": "A choice between offerings or operating alternatives could materially change the specified customer task." } ] }, { "application_id": "APP-CUSTOMER-OUTSIDE", "entry_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "role_id": "D1" }, "source_paths": [ { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I11", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I11", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-I11", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I11-C1", "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-I11-C1", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-I11-C1" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I11", "contribution_id": "C3" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I11", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-I11", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I11-C3", "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-I11-C3", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-I11-C3" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "HD-P07", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P07", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-HD-P07", "expression_ref": "X-HD-P07-C1", "mapping_ref": "MAP-HD-P07-C1", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-HD-P07-C1" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "HD-P07", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P07", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-HD-P07", "expression_ref": "X-HD-P07-C2", "mapping_ref": "MAP-HD-P07-C2", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "role_id": "O1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-HD-P07-C2" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "HD-P08", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P08", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-HD-P08", "expression_ref": "X-HD-P08-C1", "mapping_ref": "MAP-HD-P08-C1", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-HD-P08-C1" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "HD-P08", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P08", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-HD-P08", "expression_ref": "X-HD-P08-C2", "mapping_ref": "MAP-HD-P08-C2", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-HD-P08-C2" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "HD-P09", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P09", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-HD-P09", "expression_ref": "X-HD-P09-C2", "mapping_ref": "MAP-HD-P09-C2", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "role_id": "O1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-HD-P09-C2" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "HD-P10", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P10", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-HD-P10", "expression_ref": "X-HD-P10-C1", "mapping_ref": "MAP-HD-P10-C1", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-HD-P10-C1" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "HD-P10", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P10", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-HD-P10", "expression_ref": "X-HD-P10-C2", "mapping_ref": "MAP-HD-P10-C2", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-HD-P10-C2" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "HD-P11", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P11", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-HD-P11", "expression_ref": "X-HD-P11-C1", "mapping_ref": "MAP-HD-P11-C1", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-HD-P11-C1" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "HD-P11", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P11", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-HD-P11", "expression_ref": "X-HD-P11-C2", "mapping_ref": "MAP-HD-P11-C2", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-HD-P11-C2" } ], "lineage_note": "Source paths are navigation to this card, not evidence for this hypothetical case or proof of its procedure.", "required_members": [ { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "role_id": "D1" } ], "required_conditions": [ { "reference": { "owner_ref": { "kind": "card", "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE" }, "condition_id": "S1" }, "condition": { "condition_id": "S1", "kind": "applicability", "statement": "An identified customer group and task are connected to a business offering or operating choice." } }, { "reference": { "owner_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "role_id": "D1" }, "condition_id": "D-AUTH" }, "condition": { "condition_id": "D-AUTH", "kind": "applicability", "statement": "The decision-maker can assess relevant safety, obligations and commercial constraints and has authority for the proposed choice." } }, { "reference": { "owner_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "role_id": "D1" }, "condition_id": "D-EXCLUDE" }, "condition": { "condition_id": "D-EXCLUDE", "kind": "boundary", "statement": "The comparison requires ignoring a mandatory safeguard or treating an unavailable essential input as verified." } }, { "reference": { "owner_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "role_id": "D1" }, "condition_id": "D-INPUT" }, "condition": { "condition_id": "D-INPUT", "kind": "applicability", "statement": "At least two feasible alternatives, including a permitted status quo or no change, and a way to examine customer-task results can be specified." } } ], "required_objectives": [ { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "role_id": "D1", "field": "objective" } ], "required_activations": [ { "reference": { "role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-CUSTOMER-VALUE", "role_id": "D1" }, "trigger_index": 0 }, "statement": "A choice between offerings or operating alternatives could materially change the specified customer task." } ] }, { "application_id": "APP-FOLLOW-UNKNOWN", "entry_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-FOLLOW-THROUGH", "role_id": "D1" }, "source_paths": [ { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-P07", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-P07", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-P07", "expression_ref": "X-MK-P07-C1", "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-P07-C1", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-FOLLOW-THROUGH", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-P07-C1" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-P07", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-P07", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-P07", "expression_ref": "X-MK-P07-C2", "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-P07-C2", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-FOLLOW-THROUGH", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-P07-C2" } ], "lineage_note": "Source paths are navigation to this card, not evidence for this hypothetical case or proof of its procedure.", "required_members": [ { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-FOLLOW-THROUGH", "role_id": "D1" } ], "required_conditions": [ { "reference": { "owner_ref": { "kind": "card", "card_id": "QE-FOLLOW-THROUGH" }, "condition_id": "S1" }, "condition": { "condition_id": "S1", "kind": "applicability", "statement": "An identifiable commitment has been acknowledged by a responsible actor, with a completion condition that is agreed or can be clarified." } }, { "reference": { "owner_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-FOLLOW-THROUGH", "role_id": "D1" }, "condition_id": "D-CONTACT" }, "condition": { "condition_id": "D-CONTACT", "kind": "applicability", "statement": "A legitimate channel exists to clarify the obligation with the affected party or escalate it to a responsible authority." } }, { "reference": { "owner_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-FOLLOW-THROUGH", "role_id": "D1" }, "condition_id": "D-EXCLUDE" }, "condition": { "condition_id": "D-EXCLUDE", "kind": "boundary", "statement": "The procedure would require performing an unsafe or prohibited act merely to honor the original promise." } } ], "required_objectives": [ { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-FOLLOW-THROUGH", "role_id": "D1", "field": "objective" } ], "required_activations": [ { "reference": { "role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-FOLLOW-THROUGH", "role_id": "D1" }, "trigger_index": 0 }, "statement": "An acknowledged commitment is due for action or its completion is threatened." } ] }, { "application_id": "APP-FOLLOW-OUTSIDE", "entry_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-FOLLOW-THROUGH", "role_id": "D1" }, "source_paths": [ { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-P07", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-P07", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-P07", "expression_ref": "X-MK-P07-C1", "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-P07-C1", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-FOLLOW-THROUGH", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-P07-C1" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-P07", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-P07", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-P07", "expression_ref": "X-MK-P07-C2", "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-P07-C2", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-FOLLOW-THROUGH", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-P07-C2" } ], "lineage_note": "Source paths are navigation to this card, not evidence for this hypothetical case or proof of its procedure.", "required_members": [ { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-FOLLOW-THROUGH", "role_id": "D1" } ], "required_conditions": [ { "reference": { "owner_ref": { "kind": "card", "card_id": "QE-FOLLOW-THROUGH" }, "condition_id": "S1" }, "condition": { "condition_id": "S1", "kind": "applicability", "statement": "An identifiable commitment has been acknowledged by a responsible actor, with a completion condition that is agreed or can be clarified." } }, { "reference": { "owner_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-FOLLOW-THROUGH", "role_id": "D1" }, "condition_id": "D-CONTACT" }, "condition": { "condition_id": "D-CONTACT", "kind": "applicability", "statement": "A legitimate channel exists to clarify the obligation with the affected party or escalate it to a responsible authority." } }, { "reference": { "owner_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-FOLLOW-THROUGH", "role_id": "D1" }, "condition_id": "D-EXCLUDE" }, "condition": { "condition_id": "D-EXCLUDE", "kind": "boundary", "statement": "The procedure would require performing an unsafe or prohibited act merely to honor the original promise." } } ], "required_objectives": [ { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-FOLLOW-THROUGH", "role_id": "D1", "field": "objective" } ], "required_activations": [ { "reference": { "role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-FOLLOW-THROUGH", "role_id": "D1" }, "trigger_index": 0 }, "statement": "An acknowledged commitment is due for action or its completion is threatened." } ] }, { "application_id": "APP-RECOGNITION-UNKNOWN", "entry_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-RECOGNITION-DESIGN", "role_id": "D1" }, "source_paths": [ { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-P03", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-P03", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-P03", "expression_ref": "X-MK-P03-C2", "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-P03-C2", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-RECOGNITION-DESIGN", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-P03-C2" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-P04", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-P04", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-P04", "expression_ref": "X-MK-P04-C1", "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-P04-C1", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-RECOGNITION-DESIGN", "role_id": "O1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-P04-C1" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-P04", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-P04", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-P04", "expression_ref": "X-MK-P04-C2", "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-P04-C2", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-RECOGNITION-DESIGN", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-P04-C2" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I06", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I06", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-I06", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I06-C1", "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-I06-C1", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-RECOGNITION-DESIGN", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-I06-C1" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I06", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I06", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-I06", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I06-C2", "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-I06-C2", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-RECOGNITION-DESIGN", "role_id": "O1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-I06-C2" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "HD-P13", "contribution_id": "C3" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P13", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-HD-P13", "expression_ref": "X-HD-P13-C3", "mapping_ref": "MAP-HD-P13-C3", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-RECOGNITION-DESIGN", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-HD-P13-C3" } ], "lineage_note": "Source paths are navigation to this card, not evidence for this hypothetical case or proof of its procedure.", "required_members": [ { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-RECOGNITION-DESIGN", "role_id": "D1" } ], "required_conditions": [ { "reference": { "owner_ref": { "kind": "card", "card_id": "QE-RECOGNITION-DESIGN" }, "condition_id": "S1" }, "condition": { "condition_id": "S1", "kind": "applicability", "statement": "An organizational contribution, recipient and context for acknowledgment can be identified." } }, { "reference": { "owner_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-RECOGNITION-DESIGN", "role_id": "D1" }, "condition_id": "D-AUTH" }, "condition": { "condition_id": "D-AUTH", "kind": "applicability", "statement": "The actor can choose acknowledgment within available resources, privacy requirements and any compensation or award obligations." } }, { "reference": { "owner_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-RECOGNITION-DESIGN", "role_id": "D1" }, "condition_id": "D-BASIS" }, "condition": { "condition_id": "D-BASIS", "kind": "applicability", "statement": "A credible basis for attributing the contribution and a permitted way to assess recipient and context fit are available." } }, { "reference": { "owner_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-RECOGNITION-DESIGN", "role_id": "D1" }, "condition_id": "D-EXCLUDE" }, "condition": { "condition_id": "D-EXCLUDE", "kind": "boundary", "statement": "Recognition would disclose protected information, humiliate a recipient or replace an owed payment or required corrective action." } } ], "required_objectives": [ { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-RECOGNITION-DESIGN", "role_id": "D1", "field": "objective" } ], "required_activations": [ { "reference": { "role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-RECOGNITION-DESIGN", "role_id": "D1" }, "trigger_index": 0 }, "statement": "There is an occasion to acknowledge an identifiable organizational contribution." } ] }, { "application_id": "APP-RECOGNITION-OUTSIDE", "entry_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-RECOGNITION-DESIGN", "role_id": "D1" }, "source_paths": [ { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-P03", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-P03", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-P03", "expression_ref": "X-MK-P03-C2", "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-P03-C2", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-RECOGNITION-DESIGN", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-P03-C2" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-P04", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-P04", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-P04", "expression_ref": "X-MK-P04-C1", "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-P04-C1", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-RECOGNITION-DESIGN", "role_id": "O1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-P04-C1" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-P04", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-P04", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-P04", "expression_ref": "X-MK-P04-C2", "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-P04-C2", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-RECOGNITION-DESIGN", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-P04-C2" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I06", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I06", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-I06", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I06-C1", "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-I06-C1", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-RECOGNITION-DESIGN", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-I06-C1" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I06", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I06", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-I06", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I06-C2", "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-I06-C2", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-RECOGNITION-DESIGN", "role_id": "O1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-I06-C2" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "HD-P13", "contribution_id": "C3" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-HD-P13", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-HD-P13", "expression_ref": "X-HD-P13-C3", "mapping_ref": "MAP-HD-P13-C3", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-RECOGNITION-DESIGN", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-HD-P13-C3" } ], "lineage_note": "Source paths are navigation to this card, not evidence for this hypothetical case or proof of its procedure.", "required_members": [ { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-RECOGNITION-DESIGN", "role_id": "D1" } ], "required_conditions": [ { "reference": { "owner_ref": { "kind": "card", "card_id": "QE-RECOGNITION-DESIGN" }, "condition_id": "S1" }, "condition": { "condition_id": "S1", "kind": "applicability", "statement": "An organizational contribution, recipient and context for acknowledgment can be identified." } }, { "reference": { "owner_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-RECOGNITION-DESIGN", "role_id": "D1" }, "condition_id": "D-AUTH" }, "condition": { "condition_id": "D-AUTH", "kind": "applicability", "statement": "The actor can choose acknowledgment within available resources, privacy requirements and any compensation or award obligations." } }, { "reference": { "owner_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-RECOGNITION-DESIGN", "role_id": "D1" }, "condition_id": "D-BASIS" }, "condition": { "condition_id": "D-BASIS", "kind": "applicability", "statement": "A credible basis for attributing the contribution and a permitted way to assess recipient and context fit are available." } }, { "reference": { "owner_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-RECOGNITION-DESIGN", "role_id": "D1" }, "condition_id": "D-EXCLUDE" }, "condition": { "condition_id": "D-EXCLUDE", "kind": "boundary", "statement": "Recognition would disclose protected information, humiliate a recipient or replace an owed payment or required corrective action." } } ], "required_objectives": [ { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-RECOGNITION-DESIGN", "role_id": "D1", "field": "objective" } ], "required_activations": [ { "reference": { "role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-RECOGNITION-DESIGN", "role_id": "D1" }, "trigger_index": 0 }, "statement": "There is an occasion to acknowledge an identifiable organizational contribution." } ] }, { "application_id": "APP-REWARDS-UNKNOWN", "entry_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "role_id": "D1" }, "source_paths": [ { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-P20", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-P20", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-P20", "expression_ref": "X-MK-P20-C2", "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-P20-C2", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-P20-C2" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I03", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I03", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-I03", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I03-C1", "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-I03-C1", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-I03-C1" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I03", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I03", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-I03", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I03-C2", "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-I03-C2", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "role_id": "O1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-I03-C2" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I03", "contribution_id": "C3" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I03", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-I03", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I03-C3", "mapping_ref": null, "observation_ref": { "kind": "observation", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "observation_id": "OBS-MK-I03-C3" }, "assembly_role_ref": null, "assessment_ref": "EV-CASE-MK-I03-C3" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I07", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I07", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-I07", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I07-C1", "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-I07-C1", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-I07-C1" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I07", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I07", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-I07", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I07-C2", "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-I07-C2", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-I07-C2" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I09", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I09", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-I09", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I09-C1", "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-I09-C1", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "role_id": "O1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-I09-C1" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I09", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I09", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-I09", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I09-C2", "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-I09-C2", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-I09-C2" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I13", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I13", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-I13", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I13-C1", "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-I13-C1", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-I13-C1" } ], "lineage_note": "Source paths are navigation to this card, not evidence for this hypothetical case or proof of its procedure.", "required_members": [ { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "role_id": "D1" } ], "required_conditions": [ { "reference": { "owner_ref": { "kind": "card", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES" }, "condition_id": "S1" }, "condition": { "condition_id": "S1", "kind": "applicability", "statement": "An organization can change consequential rewards and observe relevant behavior." } }, { "reference": { "owner_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "role_id": "D1" }, "condition_id": "D-REVIEW" }, "condition": { "condition_id": "D-REVIEW", "kind": "applicability", "statement": "The actor has authority to review the reward rule and a feasible way to examine desired outcomes and harmful shortcuts beyond the rewarded count alone." } }, { "reference": { "owner_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "role_id": "D1" }, "condition_id": "D-RULE" }, "condition": { "condition_id": "D-RULE", "kind": "applicability", "statement": "The proposed reward, its eligibility rule and the intended contribution can be stated separately." } } ], "required_objectives": [ { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "role_id": "D1", "field": "objective" } ], "required_activations": [ { "reference": { "role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "role_id": "D1" }, "trigger_index": 0 }, "statement": "A consequential reward rule is being designed or reviewed." } ] }, { "application_id": "APP-REWARDS-OUTSIDE", "entry_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "role_id": "D1" }, "source_paths": [ { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-P20", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-P20", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-P20", "expression_ref": "X-MK-P20-C2", "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-P20-C2", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-P20-C2" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I03", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I03", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-I03", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I03-C1", "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-I03-C1", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-I03-C1" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I03", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I03", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-I03", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I03-C2", "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-I03-C2", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "role_id": "O1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-I03-C2" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I03", "contribution_id": "C3" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I03", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-I03", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I03-C3", "mapping_ref": null, "observation_ref": { "kind": "observation", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "observation_id": "OBS-MK-I03-C3" }, "assembly_role_ref": null, "assessment_ref": "EV-CASE-MK-I03-C3" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I07", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I07", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-I07", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I07-C1", "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-I07-C1", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-I07-C1" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I07", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I07", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-I07", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I07-C2", "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-I07-C2", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-I07-C2" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I09", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I09", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-I09", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I09-C1", "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-I09-C1", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "role_id": "O1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-I09-C1" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I09", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I09", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-I09", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I09-C2", "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-I09-C2", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-I09-C2" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I13", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I13", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-I13", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I13-C1", "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-I13-C1", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-I13-C1" } ], "lineage_note": "Source paths are navigation to this card, not evidence for this hypothetical case or proof of its procedure.", "required_members": [ { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "role_id": "D1" } ], "required_conditions": [ { "reference": { "owner_ref": { "kind": "card", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES" }, "condition_id": "S1" }, "condition": { "condition_id": "S1", "kind": "applicability", "statement": "An organization can change consequential rewards and observe relevant behavior." } }, { "reference": { "owner_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "role_id": "D1" }, "condition_id": "D-REVIEW" }, "condition": { "condition_id": "D-REVIEW", "kind": "applicability", "statement": "The actor has authority to review the reward rule and a feasible way to examine desired outcomes and harmful shortcuts beyond the rewarded count alone." } }, { "reference": { "owner_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "role_id": "D1" }, "condition_id": "D-RULE" }, "condition": { "condition_id": "D-RULE", "kind": "applicability", "statement": "The proposed reward, its eligibility rule and the intended contribution can be stated separately." } } ], "required_objectives": [ { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "role_id": "D1", "field": "objective" } ], "required_activations": [ { "reference": { "role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "role_id": "D1" }, "trigger_index": 0 }, "statement": "A consequential reward rule is being designed or reviewed." } ] }, { "application_id": "APP-SECOND-UNKNOWN", "entry_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-SECOND", "role_id": "D1" }, "source_paths": [], "lineage_note": "No supplied-table route. The concept derives from the pinned architecture fixture; the current method includes the explicitly versioned V01 refinement.", "required_members": [ { "kind": "relation", "card_id": "QE-EX-SECOND", "relation_id": "R3" }, { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-SECOND", "role_id": "D1" }, { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-SECOND", "role_id": "E1" } ], "required_conditions": [ { "reference": { "owner_ref": { "kind": "card", "card_id": "QE-EX-SECOND" }, "condition_id": "S1" }, "condition": { "condition_id": "S1", "kind": "applicability", "statement": "Dependencies or adaptive responses could materially change the outcome of an action." } }, { "reference": { "owner_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-SECOND", "role_id": "D1" }, "condition_id": "D-OPTIONS" }, "condition": { "condition_id": "D-OPTIONS", "kind": "applicability", "statement": "Feasible options, the affected parties' objective and a decision deadline can be stated for comparison." } }, { "reference": { "owner_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-SECOND", "role_id": "E1" }, "condition_id": "E-INPUT" }, "condition": { "condition_id": "E-INPUT", "kind": "applicability", "statement": "A candidate action, an initial outcome hypothesis and a decision time budget can be specified; uncertain links can be kept explicit." } } ], "required_objectives": [ { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-SECOND", "role_id": "D1", "field": "objective" } ], "required_activations": [ { "reference": { "role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-SECOND", "role_id": "D1" }, "trigger_index": 0 }, "statement": "Before a consequential decision with material dependencies." } ] }, { "application_id": "APP-SECOND-OUTSIDE", "entry_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-SECOND", "role_id": "D1" }, "source_paths": [], "lineage_note": "No supplied-table route. The concept derives from the pinned architecture fixture; the current method includes the explicitly versioned V01 refinement.", "required_members": [ { "kind": "relation", "card_id": "QE-EX-SECOND", "relation_id": "R3" }, { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-SECOND", "role_id": "D1" }, { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-SECOND", "role_id": "E1" } ], "required_conditions": [ { "reference": { "owner_ref": { "kind": "card", "card_id": "QE-EX-SECOND" }, "condition_id": "S1" }, "condition": { "condition_id": "S1", "kind": "applicability", "statement": "Dependencies or adaptive responses could materially change the outcome of an action." } }, { "reference": { "owner_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-SECOND", "role_id": "D1" }, "condition_id": "D-OPTIONS" }, "condition": { "condition_id": "D-OPTIONS", "kind": "applicability", "statement": "Feasible options, the affected parties' objective and a decision deadline can be stated for comparison." } }, { "reference": { "owner_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-SECOND", "role_id": "E1" }, "condition_id": "E-INPUT" }, "condition": { "condition_id": "E-INPUT", "kind": "applicability", "statement": "A candidate action, an initial outcome hypothesis and a decision time budget can be specified; uncertain links can be kept explicit." } } ], "required_objectives": [ { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-SECOND", "role_id": "D1", "field": "objective" } ], "required_activations": [ { "reference": { "role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-SECOND", "role_id": "D1" }, "trigger_index": 0 }, "statement": "Before a consequential decision with material dependencies." } ] }, { "application_id": "APP-PROVIDER-UNKNOWN", "entry_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "role_id": "O1" }, "source_paths": [ { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-P20", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-P20", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-P20", "expression_ref": "X-MK-P20-C2", "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-P20-C2", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-P20-C2" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I03", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I03", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-I03", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I03-C1", "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-I03-C1", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-I03-C1" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I03", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I03", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-I03", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I03-C2", "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-I03-C2", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "role_id": "O1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-I03-C2" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I03", "contribution_id": "C3" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I03", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-I03", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I03-C3", "mapping_ref": null, "observation_ref": { "kind": "observation", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "observation_id": "OBS-MK-I03-C3" }, "assembly_role_ref": null, "assessment_ref": "EV-CASE-MK-I03-C3" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I07", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I07", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-I07", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I07-C1", "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-I07-C1", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-I07-C1" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I07", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I07", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-I07", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I07-C2", "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-I07-C2", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-I07-C2" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I09", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I09", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-I09", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I09-C1", "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-I09-C1", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "role_id": "O1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-I09-C1" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I09", "contribution_id": "C2" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I09", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-I09", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I09-C2", "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-I09-C2", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-I09-C2" }, { "contribution_ref": { "item_id": "MK-I13", "contribution_id": "C1" }, "source_ref": "SRC-ROW-MK-I13", "raw_expression_ref": "RAW-MK-I13", "expression_ref": "X-MK-I13-C1", "mapping_ref": "MAP-MK-I13-C1", "observation_ref": null, "assembly_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "role_id": "D1" }, "assessment_ref": "EV-MK-I13-C1" } ], "lineage_note": "Source paths are navigation to this card, not evidence for this hypothetical case or proof of its procedure.", "required_members": [ { "kind": "relation", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "relation_id": "U1" }, { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES", "role_id": "O1" }, { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE-EX-TARGETS", "role_id": "O1" } ], "required_conditions": [ { "reference": { "owner_ref": { "kind": "card", "card_id": "QE-EX-INCENTIVES" }, "condition_id": "S1" }, "condition": { "condition_id": "S1", "kind": "applicability", "statement": "An organization can change consequential rewards and observe relevant behavior." } }, { "reference": { "owner_ref": { "kind": "card", "card_id": "QE-EX-TARGETS" }, "condition_id": "S1" }, "condition": { "condition_id": "S1", "kind": "applicability", "statement": "Adaptive actors can influence a measure tied to consequences they care about." } } ], "required_objectives": [], "required_activations": [] } ], "review_limits": [ "All application facts are deliberately stipulated, not sourced observations or verified author practices.", "Variants change only their explicitly named assessments. Other baseline stipulations remain unchanged.", "Source-to-application routes are navigation and provenance, not inference that a source proves a case or authorizes action." ], "catalogue_version": "qe-canonical-catalogue-0.1.0", "pilot": { "version": "qe-card-pilot-0.1.0", "identity_review": { "status": "proposal_pending_acceptance", "decisions": [ { "card_id": "QE48-C01", "input_id": "P48-01", "decision": "Author the existing reserved QE48-C01 identity. Prototype High-leverage first as D2 on this Card; keep QE48-C12 and its intake role intact pending explicit ownership acceptance.", "comparisons": [ "Trade-offs also cover incompatible requirements without scarce-resource competition.", "Time-allocation fixtures specialize a resource or objective; this definition remains general.", "D1 compares complete alternatives; D2 is a conditional incremental procedure." ], "reconsider_if": "Marginal allocation shows an independently reusable meaning outside the scoped opportunity-cost contribution, or conflicts with an existing maintained owner.", "accepted": false }, { "card_id": "QE48-C03", "input_id": "P48-03", "decision": "Author the existing reserved QE48-C03 identity with a structural O1 and diagnostic reasoning method E1.", "comparisons": [ "P48-13 recommends interventions under broader constraints; E1 only tests a flow hypothesis.", "No new decision role or terminal method family is introduced." ], "reconsider_if": "The diagnostic procedure duplicates a maintained method, or the claimed capacity bound assumes a serial model that does not fit the intended concept.", "accepted": false }, { "card_id": "QE48-C30", "input_id": "P48-30", "decision": "Author QE48-C30 as a one-role boundary principle.", "comparisons": [ "Model evaluation is a procedure; this Card states what a representation alone cannot establish.", "P48-46/O1 concerns institutional consequences and its E1 remains held.", "Box is related inspected context; this is not a recovered Korzybski quotation." ], "reconsider_if": "Review finds the scoped boundary requires a different owner, or the title implies an unsupported historical equivalence.", "accepted": false } ], "proposal_role_links": [ { "input_role_ref": "P48-01/O1", "card_id": "QE48-C01", "role_id": "O1", "treatment": "reserved_identity_authored", "accepted": false }, { "input_role_ref": "P48-01/D1", "card_id": "QE48-C01", "role_id": "D1", "treatment": "reserved_identity_authored", "accepted": false }, { "input_role_ref": "P48-12/D1", "card_id": "QE48-C01", "role_id": "D2", "treatment": "scoped_contribution_proposal", "accepted": false }, { "input_role_ref": "P48-03/O1", "card_id": "QE48-C03", "role_id": "O1", "treatment": "reserved_identity_authored", "accepted": false }, { "input_role_ref": "P48-03/E1", "card_id": "QE48-C03", "role_id": "E1", "treatment": "reserved_identity_authored", "accepted": false }, { "input_role_ref": "P48-30/E1", "card_id": "QE48-C30", "role_id": "E1", "treatment": "reserved_identity_authored", "accepted": false } ] }, "application_results": [ { "application_id": "APP-PILOT-QE48-C01-D1-READY", "entry_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE48-C01", "role_id": "D1" }, "definition_scope_review": "reviewed", "case_applicability": "conditionally_applicable", "unknown_checks": [], "failed_checks": [], "evaluated_dimensions": [ "declared_scope", "required_role_objectives", "action_activation" ], "meaning": "Only explicitly declared obligations in the uses/requires closure are assessed. Missing checks are unknown. Not empirical validation, procedure completion, or action authorization." }, { "application_id": "APP-PILOT-QE48-C01-D1-UNKNOWN", "entry_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE48-C01", "role_id": "D1" }, "definition_scope_review": "reviewed", "case_applicability": "undetermined", "unknown_checks": [ { "owner_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE48-C01", "role_id": "D1" }, "condition_id": "D-VALUES" } ], "failed_checks": [], "evaluated_dimensions": [ "declared_scope", "required_role_objectives", "action_activation" ], "meaning": "Only explicitly declared obligations in the uses/requires closure are assessed. Missing checks are unknown. Not empirical validation, procedure completion, or action authorization." }, { "application_id": "APP-PILOT-QE48-C01-D1-OUTSIDE", "entry_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE48-C01", "role_id": "D1" }, "definition_scope_review": "reviewed", "case_applicability": "outside_recorded_conditions", "unknown_checks": [], "failed_checks": [ { "owner_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE48-C01", "role_id": "D1" }, "condition_id": "D-AUTH" } ], "evaluated_dimensions": [ "declared_scope", "required_role_objectives", "action_activation" ], "meaning": "Only explicitly declared obligations in the uses/requires closure are assessed. Missing checks are unknown. Not empirical validation, procedure completion, or action authorization." }, { "application_id": "APP-PILOT-QE48-C01-D2-READY", "entry_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE48-C01", "role_id": "D2" }, "definition_scope_review": "reviewed", "case_applicability": "conditionally_applicable", "unknown_checks": [], "failed_checks": [], "evaluated_dimensions": [ "declared_scope", "required_role_objectives", "action_activation" ], "meaning": "Only explicitly declared obligations in the uses/requires closure are assessed. Missing checks are unknown. Not empirical validation, procedure completion, or action authorization." }, { "application_id": "APP-PILOT-QE48-C01-D2-UNKNOWN", "entry_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE48-C01", "role_id": "D2" }, "definition_scope_review": "reviewed", "case_applicability": "undetermined", "unknown_checks": [ { "owner_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE48-C01", "role_id": "D2" }, "condition_id": "D2-INPUT" } ], "failed_checks": [], "evaluated_dimensions": [ "declared_scope", "required_role_objectives", "action_activation" ], "meaning": "Only explicitly declared obligations in the uses/requires closure are assessed. Missing checks are unknown. Not empirical validation, procedure completion, or action authorization." }, { "application_id": "APP-PILOT-QE48-C01-D2-OUTSIDE", "entry_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE48-C01", "role_id": "D2" }, "definition_scope_review": "reviewed", "case_applicability": "outside_recorded_conditions", "unknown_checks": [], "failed_checks": [ { "owner_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE48-C01", "role_id": "D2" }, "condition_id": "D2-RESOURCE" } ], "evaluated_dimensions": [ "declared_scope", "required_role_objectives", "action_activation" ], "meaning": "Only explicitly declared obligations in the uses/requires closure are assessed. Missing checks are unknown. Not empirical validation, procedure completion, or action authorization." }, { "application_id": "APP-PILOT-QE48-C03-E1-READY", "entry_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE48-C03", "role_id": "E1" }, "definition_scope_review": "reviewed", "case_applicability": "conditionally_applicable", "unknown_checks": [], "failed_checks": [], "evaluated_dimensions": [ "declared_scope", "required_role_objectives", "action_activation" ], "meaning": "Only explicitly declared obligations in the uses/requires closure are assessed. Missing checks are unknown. Not empirical validation, procedure completion, or action authorization." }, { "application_id": "APP-PILOT-QE48-C03-E1-UNKNOWN", "entry_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE48-C03", "role_id": "E1" }, "definition_scope_review": "reviewed", "case_applicability": "undetermined", "unknown_checks": [ { "owner_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE48-C03", "role_id": "E1" }, "condition_id": "E-DATA" } ], "failed_checks": [], "evaluated_dimensions": [ "declared_scope", "required_role_objectives", "action_activation" ], "meaning": "Only explicitly declared obligations in the uses/requires closure are assessed. Missing checks are unknown. Not empirical validation, procedure completion, or action authorization." }, { "application_id": "APP-PILOT-QE48-C03-E1-OUTSIDE", "entry_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE48-C03", "role_id": "E1" }, "definition_scope_review": "reviewed", "case_applicability": "outside_recorded_conditions", "unknown_checks": [], "failed_checks": [ { "owner_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE48-C03", "role_id": "E1" }, "condition_id": "E-MODEL" } ], "evaluated_dimensions": [ "declared_scope", "required_role_objectives", "action_activation" ], "meaning": "Only explicitly declared obligations in the uses/requires closure are assessed. Missing checks are unknown. Not empirical validation, procedure completion, or action authorization." }, { "application_id": "APP-PILOT-QE48-C30-E1-READY", "entry_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE48-C30", "role_id": "E1" }, "definition_scope_review": "reviewed", "case_applicability": "conditionally_applicable", "unknown_checks": [], "failed_checks": [], "evaluated_dimensions": [ "declared_scope", "required_role_objectives", "action_activation" ], "meaning": "Only explicitly declared obligations in the uses/requires closure are assessed. Missing checks are unknown. Not empirical validation, procedure completion, or action authorization." }, { "application_id": "APP-PILOT-QE48-C30-E1-UNKNOWN", "entry_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE48-C30", "role_id": "E1" }, "definition_scope_review": "reviewed", "case_applicability": "undetermined", "unknown_checks": [ { "owner_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE48-C30", "role_id": "E1" }, "condition_id": "E-PURPOSE" } ], "failed_checks": [], "evaluated_dimensions": [ "declared_scope", "required_role_objectives", "action_activation" ], "meaning": "Only explicitly declared obligations in the uses/requires closure are assessed. Missing checks are unknown. Not empirical validation, procedure completion, or action authorization." }, { "application_id": "APP-PILOT-QE48-C30-E1-OUTSIDE", "entry_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE48-C30", "role_id": "E1" }, "definition_scope_review": "reviewed", "case_applicability": "outside_recorded_conditions", "unknown_checks": [], "failed_checks": [ { "owner_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE48-C30", "role_id": "E1" }, "condition_id": "E-PURPOSE" } ], "evaluated_dimensions": [ "declared_scope", "required_role_objectives", "action_activation" ], "meaning": "Only explicitly declared obligations in the uses/requires closure are assessed. Missing checks are unknown. Not empirical validation, procedure completion, or action authorization." }, { "application_id": "APP-PILOT-QE48-C01-D1-FORCED-CHOICE", "entry_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE48-C01", "role_id": "D1" }, "definition_scope_review": "reviewed", "case_applicability": "conditionally_applicable", "unknown_checks": [], "failed_checks": [], "evaluated_dimensions": [ "declared_scope", "required_role_objectives", "action_activation" ], "meaning": "Only explicitly declared obligations in the uses/requires closure are assessed. Missing checks are unknown. Not empirical validation, procedure completion, or action authorization." }, { "application_id": "APP-PILOT-QE48-C01-D2-KNOWN-THRESHOLD", "entry_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE48-C01", "role_id": "D2" }, "definition_scope_review": "reviewed", "case_applicability": "outside_recorded_conditions", "unknown_checks": [], "failed_checks": [ { "owner_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE48-C01", "role_id": "D2" }, "condition_id": "D2-INTERACTION" } ], "evaluated_dimensions": [ "declared_scope", "required_role_objectives", "action_activation" ], "meaning": "Only explicitly declared obligations in the uses/requires closure are assessed. Missing checks are unknown. Not empirical validation, procedure completion, or action authorization." }, { "application_id": "APP-PILOT-QE48-C01-D2-KNOWN-COMPLEMENTARITY", "entry_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE48-C01", "role_id": "D2" }, "definition_scope_review": "reviewed", "case_applicability": "outside_recorded_conditions", "unknown_checks": [], "failed_checks": [ { "owner_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE48-C01", "role_id": "D2" }, "condition_id": "D2-INTERACTION" } ], "evaluated_dimensions": [ "declared_scope", "required_role_objectives", "action_activation" ], "meaning": "Only explicitly declared obligations in the uses/requires closure are assessed. Missing checks are unknown. Not empirical validation, procedure completion, or action authorization." }, { "application_id": "APP-PILOT-QE48-C03-E1-INVENTORY-UNKNOWN", "entry_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE48-C03", "role_id": "E1" }, "definition_scope_review": "reviewed", "case_applicability": "undetermined", "unknown_checks": [ { "owner_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE48-C03", "role_id": "E1" }, "condition_id": "E-ACCOUNTING" } ], "failed_checks": [], "evaluated_dimensions": [ "declared_scope", "required_role_objectives", "action_activation" ], "meaning": "Only explicitly declared obligations in the uses/requires closure are assessed. Missing checks are unknown. Not empirical validation, procedure completion, or action authorization." }, { "application_id": "APP-PILOT-QE48-C03-E1-YIELD-OUTSIDE", "entry_role_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE48-C03", "role_id": "E1" }, "definition_scope_review": "reviewed", "case_applicability": "outside_recorded_conditions", "unknown_checks": [], "failed_checks": [ { "owner_ref": { "kind": "role", "card_id": "QE48-C03", "role_id": "E1" }, "condition_id": "E-ACCOUNTING" } ], "evaluated_dimensions": [ "declared_scope", "required_role_objectives", "action_activation" ], "meaning": "Only explicitly declared obligations in the uses/requires closure are assessed. Missing checks are unknown. Not empirical validation, procedure completion, or action authorization." } ], "source_inspection_note": "Selected published passages were inspected; source assertions and QE synthesis are not empirical validation or editorial acceptance." } }